Hidden gems: Italian restaurants in Carlstadt

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Carlstadt. This list contains 18 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Fabiano’s Pizza image
1
Fabiano’s Pizza
Pizza delivery
$$ $$
5.00 (12 reviews) (~9.62 km from centre)
Los 3 amigos & italian restaurant (Formerly food lovers) image
2
Los 3 amigos & italian restaurant (Formerly food lovers)
Central American restaurant
👍👍 Comida rica y fresca 👍 we ordered pupusas y chicharron con yuca. The food was great, not overly greasy like other pupuserias we've been to. Chicharron and yuca were cooked perfectly. Agua de jamaica was delicious too. Hope to come again and get the same great service
$$ $$
4.90 (20 reviews) (~9.79 km from centre)
Leo's Italian Ice & Ice Cream image
3
Leo's Italian Ice & Ice Cream
Ice cream shop
👍👍 Everything about this place makes me glad this gem is so close to home. I would venture to say it's the best ice cream in NJ, not just in town. The girls attending are always nice, too. The flavors my family and I love are cinnamon churro, strawberry shortcake and there ices. All are consistently th...
4.80 (124 reviews) (~8.25 km from centre)
Amanta Latina Cuisine image
4
Amanta Latina Cuisine
Dominican restaurant
4.80 (21 reviews) (~9.57 km from centre)
Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen image
5
Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 We just stopped in here after attending a funeral. We're from Philly. Not realizing that this location is take out, the staff cleaned off a table, complete with adding a centerpiece of mums, and proceeded to make us feel so welcome. The food was delicious. We had sandwiches, fries and a slice of...
$$ $$
4.70 (144 reviews) (~6.55 km from centre)
Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet - New Jersey image
6
Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet - New Jersey
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Super excited that we have a restaurant of the caliber of Enzo Bruni in our neighborhood! Let’s support it so Enzo Bruni can become a staple of our neighborhood and continues to grow! Quality ingredients, great execution of the dishes which took us back straight to the streets of il Mare vicino a Ro...
$$ $$
4.70 (82 reviews) (~9.28 km from centre)
Muriale's Trattoria & Italian Delicacies image
7
Muriale's Trattoria & Italian Delicacies
Deli
👍👍 I've been here several times recently each time I've tried something different. The food is consistently excellent and fresh,and the portions are ample. I will be back.
4.70 (63 reviews) (~5.21 km from centre)
Wallington Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant image
8
Wallington Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant
Italian restaurant
$$ $$
4.70 (41 reviews) (~1.22 km from centre)
Fat Bastard and Son's Restaurant image
9
Fat Bastard and Son's Restaurant
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Newly opened, everything is brand new and obviously very clean. A little dark inside but we sat by the window, it was a nice atmosphere. Staff is very friendly and the food is excellent and reasonably priced. Great for the locals that crave the "Old Judge" pizza!!! Plenty of seating, a nice variety...
$$ $$
4.60 (118 reviews) (~3.97 km from centre)
J&S Pork Store image
10
J&S Pork Store
Italian restaurant
$ $$$
4.60 (94 reviews) (~3.73 km from centre)
Pizzi...Cotto image
11
Pizzi...Cotto
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Do you see the size of that eggplant?! It was like 6 layers thick too! Had to weigh like 2 lbs at least lol My family ordered dinner from Pizzi Cotto last night and was not disappointed. Pictures is the eggplant parmesan dinner with spaghetti, we also ordered a chicken parm dinner and an eggplant ro...
$$ $$
4.60 (84 reviews) (~4.08 km from centre)
Prime 259 Italian Steakhouse image
12
Prime 259 Italian Steakhouse
Steak house
👍👍 What a gem & wonderful dining experience. The service provided by Miguel was exceptional. Always a smile & making sure we were taken care from start to finish. The food was amazing! For starters we had fried calamari, burrata, long hots & shrimp beeps & it was all excellent. For entrees we had shrim...
4.60 (84 reviews) (~8.85 km from centre)
Eat My Balls NJ Gourmet Café/ Food Truck image
13
Eat My Balls NJ Gourmet Café/ Food Truck
Italian restaurant
4.60 (19 reviews) (~7.25 km from centre)
Geo's Kitchen image
14
Geo's Kitchen
New American restaurant
👍👍 I've been driving by this place for a while and decided to give it a try. If your in the area and you just want something good to eat before taking a nap. This is a local spot with some reasonably priced 10/10 food.
$$ $$
4.60 (16 reviews) (~8.59 km from centre)
Tony's Pizzeria & Ristorante image
15
Tony's Pizzeria & Ristorante
Italian restaurant
$$ $$
4.60 (9 reviews) (~4.67 km from centre)
Pizza Bite image
16
Pizza Bite
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This is one of the best vegan pizzas I’ve ever had!! I know my food (I’m from New Orleans) and just moved from California where vegan options are bountiful, so I know what a good vegan pizza should taste like. I ordered the Melanzane pizza with vegan cheese instead and for delivery since I’m in a...
$$ $$
4.50 (134 reviews) (~5.35 km from centre)
John's Deli and Italian Bistro image
17
John's Deli and Italian Bistro
Deli
😠 Four of us ordered sandwiches and three of us were more than disappointed. You would expect an Italian deli to have good procuitto but it was HORRIBLE. It smells bad and tastes even worse totally inedible. My Turkey & Avocado BLT (as well as my coworker) should leave out the word avocado because thi...
4.50 (95 reviews) (~7.43 km from centre)
Gio's Pizza image
18
Gio's Pizza
Italian restaurant
$$ $$
4.50 (75 reviews) (~9.28 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Carlstadt

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )