Hidden gems: Food & Drinks in Cudahy

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Cudahy. This list contains 23 places from Food & Drinks category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Castro’s Bar image
1
Castro’s Bar
Bar
👍 I've only been there a few times at night and those were on the weekend . It's all street parking as far as I could tell but I've not had trouble finding a spot . It's Kind of a club atmosphere and a D J playing music , mostly of a Latino / Hispanic theme and very uplifting . Everything looks like i...
5.00 (20 reviews)
Reggie & Gerry's Bar image
2
Reggie & Gerry's Bar
Bar
👍👍 I can't even go in 12 💀💀💀
5.00 (8 reviews)
Landmark by the Lake Restaurant image
3
Landmark by the Lake Restaurant
Brunch restaurant
👍👍 Just like the first landmark, incredible food, atmosphere, and service! Not to mention always a fair price. Really comfortable place to get a breakfast with no frills
4.90 (60 reviews)
Halftime Social Bar image
4
Halftime Social Bar
Bar
👍👍 Beautiful bar! Always a great atmosphere with great bartenders:)
4.90 (47 reviews)
Ricas Pupusas image
5
Ricas Pupusas
Salvadoran restaurant
👍👍 Very delicious pupusas ! The lady is so nice and the pupusas are so good And can’t beat the price!
4.90 (43 reviews)
CHILInn image
6
CHILInn
Restaurant
👍👍 I used to dine at Samano's at least once a year for their delicious food and to catch up with Wendy Helgeson, who was the parent of one of my best friend's from grade school. I moved to Texas seven years ago and tried to stop in if I was in town, but was heartbroken to hear it closed permanently dur...
4.90 (18 reviews)
Porky's on Squire image
7
Porky's on Squire
Bar
👍👍 This classic Cudahy bar has recently re-opened under new owners. The bar has been remodeled but yet retains its classic neighborhood bar feel. It is a great place to socialize with friends, play a game, or come in and have a drink and make new friends. Seats are comfortable, it’s clean, lots of snac...
4.90 (14 reviews)
Leña Ardiendo Pizzería image
8
Leña Ardiendo Pizzería
Restaurant
👍👍 The pizza is very good. It has a woody flavor. I really liked it for the first time. What I liked it. The ingredients are also fresh. It looks incredible. In addition, the wings are also very good with a unique flavor. I'm going to go back to this store to try the whole menu. I'm going to recommend...
$$ $$
4.80 (87 reviews)
Tiny's: A Neighborhood Sports Tavern image
9
Tiny's: A Neighborhood Sports Tavern
Sports bar
👍👍 Great place to hang with friends! Jeff is a great addition to this establishment. Tiny is also a pretty cool dude 😎
$ $$$
4.80 (70 reviews)
L A Patisserie image
10
L A Patisserie
Bakery
👍👍 Great pastries and food. BUT even Greater Customer Service. I am going to recommend LA Patisserie to everyone I know.
4.80 (17 reviews)
Sottile's Pub image
11
Sottile's Pub
Bar
👍👍 I absolutely loved this place. Scott was extremely welcoming, and made all of us feel at home here. I will most definitely be coming back the next time we have a group outing. I am not usually into the bar scene, but if places were more like this I would be. Everything you could want in a bar. Frien...
$ $$$
4.70 (53 reviews)
East Side Ovens image
12
East Side Ovens
Wholesale bakery
👍👍 Best apple cider doughnuts in town! All their other things are the best as well . . . Pumpkin cake, brownies, fruit dumpling, churro cookies and on & on.
4.70 (40 reviews)
Cudahy Family Library image
13
Cudahy Family Library
Public library
👍👍 Definitely one of the best libraries in the entire southeastern Wisconsin area. This library embraces the concept of educating the public through books, but also through experiences, activities, and special events. It is a beautiful library, wonderful staff, and is a vital part of the community.
4.60 (148 reviews)
Orson's Saloon image
14
Orson's Saloon
Live music bar
👍👍 It was my first time at this bar and the bartender Nicki was very friendly and welcoming! The place was clean and the drinks were very reasonably priced. I will definitely go back.
$ $$$
4.60 (107 reviews)
Tacos El Pumchis image
15
Tacos El Pumchis
Taco restaurant
👍👍 CASH ONLY This truck is incredible. It's in an industrial area with lots of other food trucks. I would go out of my way for their al pastor.
$ $$$
4.60 (103 reviews)
Cudahy Country Club image
16
Cudahy Country Club
Bar
😠 I was asked to give up my seat at the bar because we had water and soda drinking non alcoholic beverage at first. So the regulars for the packer game could sit at the bar And can't have nothing to eat only for people buying alcohol. ( I get that. )We spent $90 dollars that day. You should be ashame...
$ $$$
4.60 (96 reviews)
Los Sabrosos al Horno image
17
Los Sabrosos al Horno
Taco restaurant
👍👍 Ok so read carefully! This is a definite must visit & try! The food prep & show is rare! The food is great. The chef 👨‍🍳 is on par and knows his profession. Speak with him and allow him to explain his traditional cooking from his father! Cultural food with a 👍 great taste and experience! Must tr...
4.60 (45 reviews)
Perro tacos image
18
Perro tacos
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Went to a brewery and this was the food truck outside of it. I was VERY pleasantly surprised at the quality and taste of the taco I ordered!
4.60 (17 reviews)
Bionicos La Tropicana image
19
Bionicos La Tropicana
Restaurant
👍👍 One of my favorite places to go for some healthy smoothies. Its just awesome the variety that they have in such a small space. They also have great tasting sandwiches and other snacks. I also like going for their ginger, tumeric shots.
$ $$$
4.50 (148 reviews)
Swift Kick Pub image
20
Swift Kick Pub
Pub
👍👍 Great prices and attentive bartenders keep bringing us back!
$ $$$
4.50 (131 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )