Top rated Thrift stores in East Massapequa

Experience the best that East Massapequa has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 19 places from Thrift store category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Only Rare NYC image
1
Only Rare NYC
Ice cream shop
👍👍 The rolled ice cream here is awesome. They gotta step they spoon game up though, I need a stronger spoon than them flimsy plastic ones🤷🏽‍♂️👍🏾
5.00 (114 reviews) (~25.78 km from centre)
The Vintage Living image
2
The Vintage Living
Antique store
4.90 (76 reviews) (~17.59 km from centre)
The Antique & Thrift Shop image
3
The Antique & Thrift Shop
Antique store
😠 I went to look for records. He’s got thousands of them all stacked on top of each other. Owner was getting angry at me for moving records stacked on top of other records. Most of what he’s got are dime a dozen classical records. You’re better off going to Glory Beez in Baldwin. Too crowded of a stor...
4.50 (38 reviews) (~22.03 km from centre)
Back of the Closet image
4
Back of the Closet
Clothing store
4.40 (31 reviews) (~22.01 km from centre)
Cooky'sthrift&consignment image
5
Cooky'sthrift&consignment
Thrift store
😠 Extremely overpriced… I’m never one to complain but my jaw dropped at the prices. Some clothing was ripped with hefty price tags as well. Also, some of the “designer” being sold was inauthentic. As someone who used to be in the streetwear business, it’s easy to tell the difference. Do yourself a fav...
4.30 (123 reviews) (~16.39 km from centre)
All you need is thrift image
6
All you need is thrift
Thrift store
😠 Closed? Was here at 12:30 sign said open but the store was locked and clearly closed. Update: They were open today and the guy behind the counter was kind of lazy and useless. I was better off with them closed.
4.30 (61 reviews) (~5.1 km from centre)
Savers image
7
Savers
Thrift store
Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.
$ $$$
4.20 (582 reviews) (~18.15 km from centre)
AMVETS Thrift Store image
8
AMVETS Thrift Store
Thrift store
😠 DO NOT DONATE ANYTHING to this store.This is a crime ring. You only can purchase quality items if you payoff the employees. The bling ring: GLORIA MELISSA SONYA. How much are you criminals making a week on the side? Why are some customers allowed in the back of the store to take what they want, whil...
4.20 (291 reviews) (~3.76 km from centre)
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center image
9
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center
Thrift store
😠 Used to be my favorite thrift store but has now become the most over priced thrift in all of long island. It’s so sad. Items that are sold at DOLLAR TREE are marked up to 5.99 here, they sell clothes for higher than the retail price… don’t waste your time here and head over to the local church thrif...
4.20 (66 reviews) (~25.04 km from centre)
The Junior League of Long Island Thrift Shop image
10
The Junior League of Long Island Thrift Shop
Thrift store
4.20 (55 reviews) (~23.04 km from centre)
Savers image
11
Savers
Thrift store
Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.
$ $$$
4.10 (375 reviews) (~21.27 km from centre)
Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center image
12
Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center
Thrift store
😐 Very quiet which I like .Don't see too much turnover in items .I only purchase things when the older male is there ,I've noticed whenever the women are behind the register theres always issues with pricing even though there are price tags on the items. Also, this is the only S.A I know that charges...
4.10 (82 reviews) (~23.56 km from centre)
Good Samaritan Thrift Shop image
13
Good Samaritan Thrift Shop
Thrift store
😠 Terrible experience not only did I hear the workers at the front deck referring to customers as “ those black women “ !! when my 3 year old daughter needed to go to the bathroom they refused to let her use their bathroom and told me we could walk in the 90 degree weather ( with 2 kids) to the trai...
3.90 (34 reviews) (~10.01 km from centre)
MyUnique Thrift Levittown image
14
MyUnique Thrift Levittown
Thrift store
3.80 (322 reviews) (~9.59 km from centre)
Island Thrift image
15
Island Thrift
Thrift store
😠 This place used to be my favorite thrift shop. They used to have many antiques stuff with affordable prices. The prices of their merchandises went so high to the point that it’s cheaper to buy it new than buy it from them. Even though I never bought clothes from there, I was so curios to check the p...
3.70 (208 reviews) (~18.75 km from centre)
The Salvation Army Thrift Store West Babylon, NY image
16
The Salvation Army Thrift Store West Babylon, NY
Thrift store
😐 Maybe an angel stopped at the store or the fairy godmother… A lot of great finds…. Make sure you are aware of the sale days… Have fun shopping. Update.. Seems like no one likes the new manager.. she makes up prices.. depending on the person. And if she doesn't like you she will speak Spanish to the...
3.70 (156 reviews) (~8.71 km from centre)
Second Chance Thrift Shop image
17
Second Chance Thrift Shop
Thrift store
😠 My little sister and I went here a few months ago and the two women at the desk yelled at us for accidentally bumping into something - NOT EVEN KNOCKING IT OVER OR ANYTHING. Yelled at us that if it were to break we would pay for everything that fell off that little table. They continued to stare us...
3.40 (43 reviews) (~22.76 km from centre)
Farmingdale Thrift Shop image
18
Farmingdale Thrift Shop
Thrift store
😠 Don’t waste your time here. The store is junky, untidy and very old. There are no prices on anything I saw. The price is based on how the guy behind the counter feels that day I guess. That concerns me because the price is subjective. I was wearing a blue shirt, maybe he doesn’t like blue and gav...
3.30 (38 reviews) (~6.85 km from centre)
Society of St. Vincent de Paul image
19
Society of St. Vincent de Paul
Thrift store
3.10 (119 reviews) (~21.03 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near East Massapequa

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )