Top rated Italian restaurants in Erie, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Erie

Experience the best that Erie has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 18 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Erie

Avanti's

Breakfast restaurant

👍👍 Delicious food, italian breakfast theme. Dinor atmosphere. Great wait staff

$ $$$

4.70 (853 reviews) (~3.49 km from centre)

Colao's Ristorante

Italian restaurant

Homey, family-owned spot for traditional Italian cuisine, including pastas, seafood & steaks.

$$$ $

4.60 (646 reviews) (~3 km from centre)

Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream

Italian restaurant

👍 Great local eatery...pizza is pretty good and has a nice garlic butter flavor to the crust. The ice cream and Italian ice are very good and prices are fair. Would love to see an updated interior, seating outside is nice. Parking lot is small but I've never had an issue finding a spot. I like this...

$ $$$

4.60 (374 reviews) (~7.06 km from centre)

Mi Scuzi

Italian restaurant

Warm trattoria offering authentic Italian dishes including homemade pastas plus a wine list & beer.

$$$ $

4.50 (763 reviews) (~2.38 km from centre)

Peppino's Italian Chop House

Italian restaurant

😠 I am 72 years old and have been wearing a hat most of my life, including to fancier restaurants. Went to Peppinos with a small group of people. After being there for 10 minutes, the waitress told me I had to remove my hat or I would be thrown out. This is NOT a five star restaurant. My hat was a lot...

$$ $$

4.50 (195 reviews) (~14.12 km from centre)

Skippereno's Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Our sever, Elleyn,was so courteous and promptly took care of us when we arrived and throughout our meal, thank you so much!! We had delicious cheesebread with our meal, literally melted in our mouth, so good. The 🍝 spaghetti was prepared just right and was a decent size proportion. The eggplant w...

$ $$$

4.40 (466 reviews) (~5.19 km from centre)

Mama Mia's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Pizza, calzones & other basic Italian fare served in a long-running joint with an old-school vibe.

$ $$$

4.40 (262 reviews) (~4.55 km from centre)

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads.

$$ $$

4.30 (3.6K reviews) (~7.3 km from centre)

Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Italian eatery offering a simple, comfy setting for familiar fare such as pizza, pasta & wings.

$ $$$

4.30 (1.1K reviews) (~5.35 km from centre)

Dominick's Diner, LLC

Restaurant

Informal destination for typical Italian & American eats, including breakfast & meatball omelets.

$ $$$

4.30 (944 reviews) (~0.8 km from centre)

Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Italian eatery offering a simple, comfy setting for familiar fare such as pizza, pasta & wings.

$ $$$

4.30 (636 reviews) (~7.97 km from centre)

Charlie's Pub & Eatery

Pizza restaurant

😠 Uncle Charlie's is terrible. I grew up in Edinboro and I remember when this place was a treasure. Not anymore. Ordered a pizza tonight and it CAME OUT room temperature. Not sure what they're doing, but this pizza was very obviously not fresh. Tasted like a take and bake but not as good. It actually...

$ $$$

4.30 (454 reviews) (~27.02 km from centre)

Sabo's Pizza INC

Pizza restaurant

This casual neighborhood pizzeria making combo pies, sandwiches & salads also offers patio seating.

$ $$$

4.30 (291 reviews) (~17.52 km from centre)

Ringside Restaurant

Italian restaurant

👍👍 First time here and the food was amazing. Made properly, warm and fresh. Atmosphere was homey. Service was prompt. Very historic memories wall to wall. Shout out to Angela who was very attentive and passionate with what she does. Overall, definitely a come to place when coming to Erie.

$ $$$

4.20 (240 reviews) (~7.19 km from centre)

Valerio's Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Italian eatery offering a simple, comfy setting for familiar fare such as pizza, pasta & wings.

$ $$$

4.00 (1.1K reviews) (~4.98 km from centre)

Barbato's Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Local institution dating back to 1955 offering classic pies & casual Italian eats in comfy quarters.

$$ $$

3.90 (287 reviews) (~7.27 km from centre)

Sbarro

Pizza restaurant

Italian fast-food chain offering thin-crust pizza by the slice, plus pastas & salads.

$ $$$

3.70 (46 reviews) (~6.66 km from centre)

Mike N' Dangelo's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

$ $$$

3.60 (401 reviews) (~23.74 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Erie, United States