Hidden gems: Pizza restaurants in Garden City South

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Garden City South. This list contains 17 places from Pizza restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Nicolino Gourmet Eatery image
1
Nicolino Gourmet Eatery
Pizza restaurant
Unpretentious operation offering handcrafted pizzas, sandwiches & salads with Italian flair.
5.00 (38 reviews) (~9.44 km from centre)
Picciotto image
2
Picciotto
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Every single dish our large group tried was 5 stars. Including appetizers, pizzas, pastas, wines, gelatos, etc. Whatever you choose will be delicious and very authentic Sicilian. The atmosphere is excellent. Everyone is very friendly and caring. Everything is very clean and decorations are fun and a...
$$ $$
4.80 (116 reviews) (~9.37 km from centre)
DOLCE CAFE image
3
DOLCE CAFE
Cafe
👍👍 I have never been here before, but would always drive past it. The new ownership is very friendly and the cafe is so cozy and vibey. This is a great place to catch up with a friend and have a sweet time. Also, the bathroom is clean (big plus for me). I will absolutely be coming back.
4.80 (104 reviews) (~9.36 km from centre)
Sapori's Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen image
4
Sapori's Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen
Restaurant
😠 I wish you could leave 0 stars. We ordered an $88.00 dinner for my family Slice delivers our order. The girl spills the 2 Linguine & clam sauce all over everything, comes to our door tells us she spilled it. We refuse it because everything is covered in clam sauce she gets nasty. long story sho...
$$ $$
4.80 (51 reviews) (~8.16 km from centre)
Teddy's Restaurant & Bar image
5
Teddy's Restaurant & Bar
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 We had SUCH a nice time there!! The pizza was amazing and the owner, Lou, was so personable and accommodating. We shared stories and jokes. Will DEFINITELY be visiting again! Highly recommend this neighborhood bar/pizzeria.
4.80 (45 reviews) (~3.95 km from centre)
Interiano's Pizzeria & Ristorante image
6
Interiano's Pizzeria & Ristorante
Pizza restaurant
$$ $$
4.70 (120 reviews) (~7.88 km from centre)
Angelo's Pizza image
7
Angelo's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Love it just love it my dad makes soo much effort into the pizza. He makes it with passion and Loiyalty and my favorite slice he makes is the pasta slice so if you’re going to order that’s the pest one there. Keep up the good work
$$ $$
4.70 (99 reviews) (~4.24 km from centre)
Edesma image
8
Edesma
Greek restaurant
👍👍 Wow what a delight! I had the penne siciliana today with a glass of Pinot Grigio. Great portions - I even had a touch for lunch tomorrow. Must try!
$$ $$
4.60 (142 reviews) (~1.15 km from centre)
Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City image
9
Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City
Pizza restaurant
🫤 walked in at 5:30p expecting fresh pizza, and everything had been siting for hours, dry and coagulated. i was told there was s fresh plain pizza but it needed reheating-and you could tell it wasn’t that fresh. very disappointed considering the reviews. no need to return.
$ $$$
4.60 (131 reviews) (~1.63 km from centre)
Domino's Pizza image
10
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
👍👍 I had a fantastic experience at this new Domino's Pizza location. The pizza here is notably better than what I've experienced at the Merrick Road location. The quality of their pizza is truly a pleasant surprise. I hope this new location maintains the high standards they've set, as it's a welcome ch...
4.60 (112 reviews) (~5.11 km from centre)
Bravo Pizza Five Towns image
11
Bravo Pizza Five Towns
Pizza restaurant
$ $$$
4.60 (55 reviews) (~9.16 km from centre)
Brooklyn Dip & Burger image
12
Brooklyn Dip & Burger
Bar
👍👍 Food is great, fast and friendly service…ordered this amazing burger called the “off menu” and have also had the Williamsburger, absolutely delicious. Don’t forget to get fries they are perfectly crispy and tasty. Come hungry leave happy!
$$ $$
4.60 (45 reviews) (~3.14 km from centre)
Vaccaros Pizza image
13
Vaccaros Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😠 The worst place I’ve ever got pizza from. The customer service is the worst. I tried ordering over the phone and I’m asking my kids and my wife what did they want to order. The gentleman on the phone taking my order was rude because we didn’t decide fast enough on what pizza to order. He then pro...
$$ $$
4.50 (145 reviews) (~4.43 km from centre)
Francesca's Pizzeria image
14
Francesca's Pizzeria
Italian restaurant
Casual setting for pizza rustica & Italian dishes made with locally sourced produce.
$$ $$
4.50 (138 reviews) (~9.76 km from centre)
Big Joe's Pizzeria image
15
Big Joe's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍 Order from them twice so far. Giving them 4 stars because we've only had the regular pizza and the grandma pie so far. Both were really good and we will be going back to them again.
$ $$$
4.50 (130 reviews) (~9.76 km from centre)
Tony D’s Pizzeria image
16
Tony D’s Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Knowing Anthony since elementary school thru high school, I couldnt wait to try his pizza when I saw it in the paper. Living an hour away I went to my parents house to finally try the pizza. Now being keto I went for the caulifower pizza. I got the cauliflower marinara and the ricotta pesto which I...
$$ $$
4.50 (116 reviews) (~7.79 km from centre)
Pizza Amore image
17
Pizza Amore
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Great food cash only, New owner new place name is Scottios. Haven't been there recently since they closed for a wedding but If I see em open will do a brand new review...
4.50 (46 reviews) (~7.98 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Garden City South

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )