Top rated Thrift stores in Highland Park

Experience the best that Highland Park has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 21 places from Thrift store category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Gift To Earth Thrift Store image
1
Gift To Earth Thrift Store
Thrift store
👍👍 Wonderful thrifting experience! Super clean, organized, and TRADITIONAL thrifting prices!! Will absolutely be back! They also donate a portion of their proceeds to planet conservation. Win, win!!!!
5.00 (170 reviews) (~11.22 km from centre)
Cash 4 Gold Trading Post image
2
Cash 4 Gold Trading Post
Pawn shop
4.90 (41 reviews) (~11.24 km from centre)
Bo's Attic image
3
Bo's Attic
Consignment shop
4.80 (234 reviews) (~28.68 km from centre)
Cash 4 Gold Trading Post image
4
Cash 4 Gold Trading Post
Pawn shop
👍👍 Very reasonable and friendly. They give the best price in town. Definitely try them first and don’t confuse them with neighboring shops.
4.70 (47 reviews) (~1.73 km from centre)
Inspirations image
5
Inspirations
Thrift store
👍👍 Great prices. I purchased this jacket and made a few changes
4.50 (105 reviews) (~25.84 km from centre)
Bridge Life Thrift image
6
Bridge Life Thrift
Thrift store
😠 It’s illegal to change the posted price when the customer goes to the counter to purchase. Regardless of what u think u are selling u need to honor those prices. This illegal practice is known as bait n switch . It’s totally illegal ..Any manager in retail should know this. It makes the store loose...
4.40 (76 reviews) (~15.88 km from centre)
Bargain Box Thrift Shop image
7
Bargain Box Thrift Shop
Thrift store
4.40 (51 reviews) (~28.56 km from centre)
Inspirations image
8
Inspirations
Thrift store
😠 Absolutely terrible customer service… they have raised prices a lot! Please be aware when they are checking you out… they have items with tickets that are hiding and then if you are buying multiple items they will add in a very expensive ticket while talking to you. Once I paid, I stepped aside and...
4.30 (118 reviews) (~11.45 km from centre)
Westfield Service League Thrift Shop image
9
Westfield Service League Thrift Shop
Thrift store
👍 My 1st visit after hearing glowing reports. The staff is pleasant and accommodating. Full disclosure, I'm not much of a consignment/thrift store shopper. That said, the selection I'm afraid to say for fear of causing a run on the location, exceeds my expectation. Plan to spend more time than money...
4.30 (39 reviews) (~18.61 km from centre)
Inspirations Stores image
10
Inspirations Stores
Thrift store
😐 I've been to this place many times. I always find at least one good thing every time I go but you have to be patient. I dig through a lot of things to find one thing I like. Also, the workers are kinda rude. I dress kinda alternativly, today I went in with a friend and we both had dramatic eye liner...
4.20 (235 reviews) (~25.91 km from centre)
Raritan Valley Habitat for Humanity ReStore image
11
Raritan Valley Habitat for Humanity ReStore
Thrift store
4.20 (113 reviews) (~14.69 km from centre)
Rise Thrift Store image
12
Rise Thrift Store
Thrift store
4.20 (105 reviews) (~26.61 km from centre)
Nearly New Shop image
13
Nearly New Shop
Consignment shop
😠 Great thrift shop that I enjoy exploring, but I’m often so disappointed by the customer service. I went in to consign brand items twice in the past year, silk, wool sweaters, brands like Sandro, Ted Baker and Tommy Hilfiger and the staff (and the owner) were rude and unpleasant. I was lectured to br...
4.20 (67 reviews) (~25.09 km from centre)
Inspirations image
14
Inspirations
Thrift store
😠 I drove a half hour to get to this stored arrived at 6:25 … it’s listed that they close at 7 pm … by 6:38 they said the store was closed and we couldn’t shop anymore …. If your store closes at 7 don’t alienate your customers and have them leave early …. Terrible experience and terrible customer se...
4.10 (463 reviews) (~17.88 km from centre)
AC Vintage Clothing image
15
AC Vintage Clothing
Thrift store
4.00 (37 reviews) (~10.95 km from centre)
MyUnique Thrift Elizabeth image
16
MyUnique Thrift Elizabeth
Thrift store
Chain for used clothing, home goods, toys, books & electronics, in partnership with local charities.
3.90 (648 reviews) (~25.87 km from centre)
MyUnique Thrift South Plainfield image
17
MyUnique Thrift South Plainfield
Thrift store
😠 A couple of occasions I have come here. They had a PlayStation two. I bought the PlayStation and they took it from me at the register and tried to make me pay for the controllers and power cords all separate. Now when you buy a gaming system everything comes with it. Apparently not here. They sell a...
3.90 (542 reviews) (~9.36 km from centre)
2nd Ave Thrift Superstore - Union, NJ image
18
2nd Ave Thrift Superstore - Union, NJ
Thrift store
🫤 This is a prime example of what happens when a hedge fund owned for profit thrift store goes public on the US stock exchange. Now valued at 3 billion dollars, Savers, the parent company of 2nd Avenue has pretty much ruined this thrift store location. Constant empty racks, no more changing rooms, mos...
3.90 (478 reviews) (~25.75 km from centre)
MyUnique Thrift Union image
19
MyUnique Thrift Union
Thrift store
😠 I’ve been visiting this thrift store at this location for nearly a decade and my last visit confirmed for me that I’ll never be visiting again. Whoever is in charge of pricing the inventory is out of their mind. More expensive than shopping retail. This store epitomizes corporate greed….
3.70 (658 reviews) (~24.24 km from centre)
Yellow Tag Thrift Store & Donation Center image
20
Yellow Tag Thrift Store & Donation Center
Thrift store
3.20 (229 reviews) (~12.57 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Highland Park

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )