1
Sal's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 For 29 Years Sals Pizza has been serving Stanhope.with authentic New York style Pizza. Out of the past 50 pizzerias that I have visited over the past 2 months, I have not seen anyone who has the passion for pizza like Sal. He came around the corner and talked the finer details that go into producing...
$ $$$
4.60 (343 reviews)
(~4.98 km from centre)
2
Frank's Pizza (Hopatcong)
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Had my daughters baptism here and service was ridiculously good. Sergio and Lubia really went above and beyond to make this experience as stress free as possible. The food was amazing! I would 100% cater from them again and even have another event here.
$$ $$
4.50 (503 reviews)
(~0.24 km from centre)
3
Cambiotti's Tomato Pie Cafe
Italian restaurant
👍 Tomato pie. Best pizza this side of the Delaware. The pizza is for sure the star here. There’s no other like it, Thin crust and crispy. Sauce is a little tangy and sweet and cheese is fresh. The rest is average Italian fare. Wasn’t thrilled with the 2 meatball spaghetti dinner I got, but once again...
$$ $$
4.50 (422 reviews)
(~3.27 km from centre)
4
Vinny & Son Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant (Lake Hopatcong)
Pizza restaurant
😐 There is a ton of potential with this slice of Pizza, but they need to bring it all together. Once slice all I tasts was the cheese, next slice was all crust and finally slice 3 I got to taste the sauce which was very good. Usually I eat just one slice, so I gave this pizza every opportunity to spe...
$$ $$
4.50 (242 reviews)
(~4.44 km from centre)
5
The Grotto Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
Longtime pizzeria featuring assorted pies, plus pasta dishes & sandwiches in a simple setting.
$ $$$
4.50 (205 reviews)
(~1 km from centre)
6
The Windlass
Restaurant
Spacious lakeside restaurant serving Italian fare amid nautical accents & a boat-shaped bar.
$$ $$
4.40 (1.8K reviews)
(~3.13 km from centre)
7
Knot Just Pizza
Pizza restaurant
🫤 Just an average slice of Pizza on the Pizza Hunters App. The main aspect that hits you is the creamy cheese, which is a blend of 2 cheeses. Other than that, there was little to no sauce and the crust was middle of the road. Tried to strike up some Pizza talk, but didn't get much interest in return....
$ $$$
4.30 (185 reviews)
(~1.25 km from centre)
8
Tuscana's Pizzeria & Restaurant 2
Pizza restaurant
👍 Found this spot and decided to get lunch. I called in my order of the shrimp and broccoli with white sauce lunch special. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked in and grabbed my food. I already paid over the phone. When I dug in the meal was good. It was seasoned nicely. The broccoli wa...
$$ $$
4.30 (99 reviews)
(~0.28 km from centre)
9
Frank's Trattoria (Byram)
Pizza restaurant
😐 Very Big Pizzeria with a lot of seating. I am sure they have a goid business in Stanhope with the catering..The Pizza.. A good slice for a local pizzeria that seemed to be your standard strip mall slice. Did not taste much sauce, the cheese was plentiful and took over the slice. The crust was ok. Lo...
$ $$$
4.10 (237 reviews)
(~4.91 km from centre)
10
Frank's Pizza (Mt. Arlington)
Pizza restaurant
Classic & specialty pies, plus pasta & other Italian staples, presented in a time-tested setup.
$$ $$
4.00 (229 reviews)
(~3.9 km from centre)
11
Pizza Express (Mt. Arlington)
Pizza restaurant
Chain pizzeria where chefs in striped t-shirts toss handmade pizzas in a relaxed space.
$ $$$
4.00 (208 reviews)
(~2.54 km from centre)