Top rated Fish stores in Islip, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Fish stores in Islip

Experience the best that Islip has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 107 places from Fish store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Islip

Cold Spring Fish

Fish store

5.00 (46 reviews) (~102.24 km from centre)

Island Fish and Scale

Aquarium shop

👍👍 Dealing with Ryan is the best experience you could ask for. If you’re look for someone honest, knowledgeable, and who truly cares about the hobby then reach out to island fish and scale. One of the best things I have done

5.00 (32 reviews) (~16.94 km from centre)

Fitz's Fish Ponds

Pond contractor

👍👍 We are very satisfied with our pond designed and built by Fitz Fish ponds. Tim took the time to come visit our house and discuss possible layouts and designs. Our pond was completed on time and on budget. The FFP crew took the extra steps to minimize any impact on our yard from the equipment use to...

4.90 (288 reviews) (~116.85 km from centre)

OSA Aquarium Superstore & Services -Coventry RI

Tropical fish store

👍👍 This Place is great. The workers there are super friendly and helpful. I havent had a single issue with their fish or products. So far the best place in RI to get fish. You can tell the fish and corals are meticulously cared for. Favorite fish store.

4.80 (347 reviews) (~165.47 km from centre)

Aquarium Care Center

Tropical fish store

👍👍 This place is great! The fish are amazing, they have a TON of supplies for aquariums, the employees actually know stuff about fish and they supply us with great customer service. The prices are reasonable, not bad but its what you expect to pay for quality.

4.80 (344 reviews) (~98.53 km from centre)

TSM Aquatics, Inc

Aquarium shop

👍👍 Very impressive tanks and setup for the coral and fish, knowledgeable staff for a first time visit having done saltwater myself for 10+years, worth the drive if you live far away for sure, very clean and an amazing quarantine process and know your fish is eating and in a great condition during purch...

4.80 (195 reviews) (~183.78 km from centre)

Reefco Aquariums - Showroom and Service

Aquarium shop

👍👍 Easily the best shop for coral in NJ. Staff was very helpful and even clipped the end off the frag plug for me. They had a great selection of ricordea, and I picked one up for an even better price. I'll be a repeat customer, I'm not sure why I'd bother going anywhere else.

4.80 (147 reviews) (~118.83 km from centre)

Advanced Marine Aquatics

Tropical fish store

👍👍 Advanced Marine Aquatics has a wealth of knowledge and the best selection of marine fish on long island. Great prices with constantly changing corals and fish, A huge selection. Easy to find and great parking. I don't work there but buy all my needs there...I no longer bother with other shops cause...

4.80 (134 reviews) (~45.02 km from centre)

Menemsha Fish Market

Seafood market

👍👍 Amazing chowder and lobster rolls. For some reason the “other seafood place” next door had a long line and Menemsha Fish did not. Both are great but I think Menemsha is slightly better. Great prices (for MV), good service, fantastic location and I highly recommend! It’s takeout only or seafood for c...

4.70 (552 reviews) (~207.4 km from centre)

Pickering Valley Feed & Farm Store

Pet supply store

4.70 (391 reviews) (~228.78 km from centre)

Monte's Fish Fry & Seafood Market

Seafood market

👍👍 Me and my girlfriend drove out to seaside boardwalk stopped here beforehand. Was not disappointed . Food was super fresh and the family who runs the business showed great hospitality. A must if your craving fresh delicious food.

4.70 (194 reviews) (~125.38 km from centre)

COSMO AQUARIUM Fish Store

Tropical fish store

4.70 (158 reviews) (~64.65 km from centre)

LakFood

Asian grocery store

4.70 (66 reviews) (~49.25 km from centre)

Cassidy's Fish Market

Seafood market

👍👍 Great variety of fish & shellfish... And mini-key lime pies, too. Cash or check only, & the ATM at Viking Village charges $3.99 for withdrawal.

4.70 (63 reviews) (~141.47 km from centre)

Point Lobster Co

Seafood restaurant

👍👍 Delicious lunch on the outside patio. Hot Lobster rolls were wonderful. Lobster meat was sautéed in warm butter and served on a fresh soft bun. We tried the New England and Manhattan Clam Chowder. Both had great flavor and lots of tender fresh clams. You can tell the Fried Calamari is very fresh...

$$ $$

4.60 (886 reviews) (~108.34 km from centre)

Crab Stop

Crab house

👍👍 If you want the bang for your buck and more than this is the spot to go to. It's not somewhere you'd think to stop at first but it definitely should be. One bushel will last you over a week the way they stuff them oh my God! They're so juicy and delicious I will be back at LEAST twice a month. My fa...

4.60 (355 reviews) (~193.11 km from centre)

House of Fins

Tropical fish store

👍👍 House of Fins sets the standard for fish stores in the tri-state. They have an unmatched selection of livestock and products, managed by very professional and knowledgeable staff. This is a place you must visit if you love fish keeping.

4.60 (160 reviews) (~50.96 km from centre)

Tropical Island Aquarium Salt Water Fish Store Long Island

Pet store

👍👍 Extremely friendly & very knowledgeable staff. They take there time to explain any questions you may have. Great prices with a lot of selections of corals/fishes. Highly recommended to everyone looking for a caring store. We’ve been to different places & nothing compares to them!

4.60 (154 reviews) (~18.51 km from centre)

Country Critters Ltd

Pet supply store

🫤 This could be a thriving store, but the owner is not a nice guy. I have been in the pet industry for 40 years. The positive is that it's a beautiful store and maintained, Too often understocked and overpriced. I understand how expensive it is to stay open, and that all prices to do so have increased...

4.50 (900 reviews) (~9 km from centre)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.50 (747 reviews) (~196.09 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Fish stores in Islip, United States