1
Eta Pie
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Finally some good pie! If you're like me and tend to not like traditional red sauce they have like 6? sauce options! Soooooo many fresh toppings to choose from as well. The crust is delicious. Owners/employees are doing an awesome job. Will be back for certain. Get creative and eta pie. Or a salad...
$ $$$
4.90 (227 reviews)
2
More Than Pizza Ithaca
Pizza restaurant
👍 Good food. Great prices. Stays open when everything else in Ithaca Commons closes. The guy who took my order was rude.
$ $$$
4.70 (39 reviews)
3
Franco's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Delicious local pizza place. We each got a couple slices. Perfectly cooked crust. Nice and thin and a good crisp.
4.60 (606 reviews)
4
Italian Carry Out
Italian restaurant
Straightforward pizzeria serving pies, wings, subs & pastas in a relaxed environment.
$$ $$
4.60 (260 reviews)
5
Ned's Pizza NY
Pizza restaurant
Simple counter-serve joint for specialty pies, plus wings, subs, salads & calzones.
$ $$$
4.50 (616 reviews)
6
Sal's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Wow. I feel at a lost that I did know Sal's pizzeria did not existed here in Ithaca NY. I spoke with a man who had been frequenting Sal's for over thirty years. Thirty years! And he describes it as " classic and convenient." He further stated that Sal's is the best pizzeria he knows. I on my first t...
$$ $$
4.50 (339 reviews)
8
Souvlaki House
Greek restaurant
Casual destination for hefty portions of Italian & Greek classics such as pizza, pasta & gyros.
$ $$$
4.40 (328 reviews)
9
Pizza Aroma
Pizza restaurant
Small, easygoing pizzeria offering a variety of creatively topped pies, plus calzones & vegan bites.
$$ $$
4.40 (246 reviews)
10
Casablanca Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍 For those confused, the pizzeria and the restaurant that is right on top of the pizzeria on google is the exact same - you can get pizza but there are other options too.
I got the lamb and chicken over rice and it also comes with some vegetables (pictured below). Overall, it was a good amount of fo...
$$ $$
4.20 (297 reviews)
11
Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Carry-out chain featuring chicken wings, signature breadsticks & pizza tossed from housemade dough.
$ $$$
4.00 (182 reviews)
12
Pudgie's Pizza & Subs
Pizza restaurant
😠 Pudgies has one of my two favorite pizzas in Ithaca. However, this week with home projects and an overnight shift, I decided to call for delivery before work. BIG MISTAKE! Phoned at 7:35pm Family pack with a two topping pizza told it would be about 45 minutes. Delivery completed at 8:25pm. Get...
$ $$$
3.90 (208 reviews)
13
Papa Johns Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
$ $$$
3.50 (391 reviews)
14
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.
$ $$$
3.40 (286 reviews)
15
Pronto Craft Pizza
Delivery service
😠 PRONTO PIZZA NOT LIVING UP TO ITS NAME.
My colleague ordered two overpriced (and come to find out, undersized) pizzas and was told they would come in 40 minutes. She called an hour later to find out it would be another 30 to 45 minutes. We proceeded to find no pizza another 50 minutes later. My fri...
$ $$$
3.00 (77 reviews)
16
Mama Teresa's Pizzeria
Restaurant
😠 I never give one stars but this place really sucked. Ate twice from here as it us really close to my place. The pizza was quite underwhelming for a pizzeria . However, what was really terrible was the terrible value for money on their fried chicken. I was given one big chicken breast and three super...
$$ $$
2.10 (54 reviews)