Top rated Caribbean restaurants in Key West

Experience the best that Key West has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 13 places from Caribbean restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Wasacaca KW Venezuelan Food image
1
Wasacaca KW Venezuelan Food
Caribbean restaurant
👍👍 Delicious Venezuelan food, 100% recommended. My husband and me ordered parrilla and tequeños with original Venezuelan Malta and all food was amazing! Also the owner gift us 3 small cachapas with complimentary cheese that were also super good.
5.00 (62 reviews)
Pepper Pot Island Cafe image
2
Pepper Pot Island Cafe
Caribbean restaurant
👍👍 If you are looking for a local secret, off-the-beaten-path place serving authentic Caribbean food, this is the place for you. The food was amazing, and the Key lime habanero sauce so good we bought a bottle for home.
$$ $$
4.90 (208 reviews)
Mo's Restaurant image
3
Mo's Restaurant
Caribbean restaurant
Chill, inviting eatery with classic Creole & island comfort eats, including renowned Key lime pie.
$$ $$
4.70 (616 reviews)
The Jerk image
4
The Jerk
Jamaican restaurant
👍👍 One of the best Jamaican restaurants in the world!!!! I'm not sure who thought him how to cook but I want to thank you. The flavors are perfect, customer service great, the food is cooked with love. The amount of food is enough for 2 people. I am so happy this place was recommended. Nothing bad t...
$ $$$
4.70 (402 reviews)
Blue Heaven image
5
Blue Heaven
American restaurant
Iconic landmark for Floridian-Caribbean cuisine & key lime pie, with a funky setting.
$$ $$
4.60 (9.2K reviews)
Yahman's Authentic Jamaican Jerk Shack/Sweetest Knights image
6
Yahman's Authentic Jamaican Jerk Shack/Sweetest Knights
Jamaican restaurant
🫤 Located inside a meal prep business. After seeing food sitting in a warmer started to leave but I didn't, should've. Had chicken, ribs, and pork, wouldn't recommend any of it. Food was dry and bland, bbq sauce was pretty good. Would not return.
$$ $$
4.60 (118 reviews)
Caroline's Cafe image
7
Caroline's Cafe
American restaurant
American cafe serving po' boys, conch fritters & the like in a circa-1838 house with outdoor seats.
$$ $$
4.50 (4.2K reviews)
Bagatelle image
8
Bagatelle
Seafood restaurant
Seafood-focused American eatery set in an 1884 house with wraparound balconies for people-watching.
$$ $$
4.50 (2.2K reviews)
Cafe Sole image
9
Cafe Sole
Modern French restaurant
Cozy, romantic spot serving French-Caribbean fare, signature hog snapper & a broad wine list.
$$$ $
4.50 (675 reviews)
El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar image
10
El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar
Cuban restaurant
Veteran Cuban eatery draws crowds with rustic look, live music & Mallory Square sunset celebration.
$$ $$
4.30 (4.3K reviews)
Dante's Key West Pool Bar & Restaurant image
11
Dante's Key West Pool Bar & Restaurant
Restaurant
A swimming pool with waterfall & tiki bars draw revelers to this DJ-fueled hangout serving seafood.
$$ $$
4.30 (2.2K reviews)
Mangoes Restaurant image
12
Mangoes Restaurant
Caribbean restaurant
A big outdoor patio overlooking a bustling street attracts crowds to this fish-focused eatery & bar.
$$ $$
4.20 (1.7K reviews)
Southernmost Beach Café image
13
Southernmost Beach Café
American restaurant
Beachfront, open-air cafe serving American fare amid ocean blue walls, French cafe chairs & a bar.
$$ $$
3.90 (1.2K reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )