1
Tom's Burned Down Cafe
Bar
👍 Howdy, island adventurers! I recently had the pleasure of stumbling upon the one-of-a-kind Tom's Burned Down Cafe on Madeline Island, Wisconsin, and let me tell ya, it was a quirky experience like no other. Now, let's start with the name itself - Tom's Burned Down Cafe. Yes, you read that right. Thi...
$ $$$
4.60 (459 reviews)
(~0.06 km from centre)
3
Beach Club on Madeline Island
Bar & grill
👍👍 Please please order the Chicken Strips… 9.5/10 and if you want my type of Chicken Strip… this is it. Best I have had yet and I get them every time I come to Madeline Island. Might I even say, it’s worth the Ferry Ride over to get them.
Staff are friendly, food is always good, sitting outside is the...
$ $$$
4.30 (461 reviews)
(~0.12 km from centre)
4
Rockhouse Food Truck
Restaurant
👍👍 Holy cow!!! These guys know how to make a burger! The meat was cooked to perfection, the bun was not soggy, and the sauce they used completed the whole experience. They open at 11am and it is the go to lunch stop while at Madeline Island.
$ $$$
4.90 (53 reviews)
(~0.32 km from centre)
5
Pub Restaurant & Wine Bar
Restaurant
👍👍 The purpose of my review is to applaud Daisy the server who put up with the most entitled boorish a-hole I have ever encountered.
Two older couples come in and sit very close by. This jack@ss was a thin balding guy who took what’s left of his hair and tied it back in a pink elastic ponytail holder....
4.10 (135 reviews)
(~0.71 km from centre)
6
Cafe Seiche
American restaurant
👍👍 The food was excellent! I had the Whitefish salad sandwich and it was better than any tuna salad I've ever had and my wife had roast beef that was also incredible and the best part was that it was served up fresh with in about 4 minutes time which is faster than any drive-through I've ever been in L...
4.40 (59 reviews)
(~0.04 km from centre)
7
Inn On Madeline Island
Hotel
Relaxed resort offering lakeside quarters, a private beach, & an outdoor pool, plus tennis & dining.
4.10 (109 reviews)
(~0.71 km from centre)
8
Mission Hill Coffee House
Coffee shop
😠 The coffee is horrible. Unfortunately, it’s the only place to get coffee on the island, so people keep trying. I ordered a “Depth Charge” espresso with coffee. When I got back to my hotel, I added some creamer to it that I brought along. The creamer immediately curdled when it hit the coffee, and I...
4.00 (111 reviews)
(~0.03 km from centre)
9
Farmhouse Kitchen and Inn
Restaurant
👍👍 Every time I stop, I look forward to seeing what the rotating options are! There's usually a smaller selection, but everything is delicious. The staff is always top notch-kind, patient, and very good with the droves of tourists. (I've been in hospitality in a tourist city for a decade - mad respect...
3.90 (116 reviews)
(~0.24 km from centre)
10
Madeline Island Golf Club
Golf club
😠 Terrible. Bad. Trash. Awful. Some members are very rude. Some staff are mean. Not welcoming to the public. The fairways are not well cut. Clovers all over. Sand traps are full of water. The 18 holes are basically all the same. Would not recommend. DEFINITELY will not come back.
3.80 (47 reviews)
(~1.3 km from centre)