Best Pet supply stores in Lake Success, United States to visit (UPDATED May, 2024)

Best places: Pet supply stores in Lake Success

Discover the best places in Lake Success, curated using our unique algorithm blending 'Top Rated' and 'Most Reviewed' establishments. Uncover the city's gems and must-visit locales for an unforgettable experience. This list contains 69 places from Pet supply store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Lake Success

Pet Supplies Plus Valley Stream

Pet supply store

Chain carrying natural & U.S.-made pet supplies, plus services such as grooming & adoption.

$ $$$

4.60 (596 reviews) (~11.45 km from centre)

Fussy Friends Pet Supplies

Pet store

😐 Pretty expensive but large selection of common pet items. Tons of different foods and toys to choose from. They also have more specialty stuff like exotic animal products. I found a dog crate there for my dog but couldn’t commit to buying when I noticed it was listed in shop for $100, but selling o...

4.70 (315 reviews) (~28.04 km from centre)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.40 (3.3K reviews) (~23.16 km from centre)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.40 (1.5K reviews) (~20.06 km from centre)

Wespaw Pets

Pet supply store

👍👍 Very glad this place is in the neighborhood! I must admit I do buy the majority of my pet supplies online in bulk for convenience, but I always come here if I want to try new products, run out of stuff or want a specific recommendation from an actual human being. Their prices are extremely comparabl...

4.70 (191 reviews) (~17.33 km from centre)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.40 (1K reviews) (~15.85 km from centre)

pupculture

Dog day care center

😠 TERRIBLE experience and service ... my dog is completely unrecognizable! Just moved to the neighborhood and left a wonderful groomer that is a little too far to use, so I decided to try this place for a dog groom. Had the absolute WORST experience – the groomer ignored my request and photo I showed...

4.70 (173 reviews) (~24.68 km from centre)

Nature's Reef & Reptile

Pet store

👍👍 Came here nearly a year ago now for my first Crested Gecko...staff was extremely helpful, and very patient with me. To me, the prices were fair. Educated me on how to take care of my new gecko, and a year later, she's honestly great. Super sweet temperament, and doing well. I'm looking to get anothe...

4.60 (224 reviews) (~11.98 km from centre)

COSMO AQUARIUM Fish Store

Tropical fish store

4.70 (158 reviews) (~14.07 km from centre)

Brooklyn Zoo & Aquarium Pet Store

Pet store

Spacious shop offering puppies, kittens, fish, birds, exotics & supplies, plus grooming & boarding.

4.40 (594 reviews) (~23.73 km from centre)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

4.30 (1.9K reviews) (~14.76 km from centre)

PetSmart

Pet supply store

Chain featuring a range of pets, supplies & food (most offer grooming, boarding & other services).

$$ $$

4.30 (1.5K reviews) (~24.79 km from centre)

PetSmart

Pet supply store

Chain featuring a range of pets, supplies & food (most offer grooming, boarding & other services).

4.30 (1.2K reviews) (~23.1 km from centre)

Treat Your Pet

Pet supply store

👍👍 Very helpful over the phone. Stock checks over the phone can be a handful when you’re working retails, to the point where other chain pet stores have begun to forbid it. But that’s where a more boutique local store helps in getting down and dirty into inventory. Even willing to check/place shipments...

5.00 (83 reviews) (~19.53 km from centre)