1
Paradise Ice Cream
Ice cream shop
👍👍 My family and I moved out here to mastic beach about a month ago and at first I was a little nervous about the area. I keep finding these great areas and from the great reviews my family went last night and I had the banana split and my wife and daughter had the sundae and besides the excellent ser...
$ $$$
4.80 (223 reviews)
3
EmpanadaVille
Puerto Rican restaurant
👍👍 This family owned business is a must visit. We had last minute company for Super Bowl and instead of the easy pizza route, we opted to take a shot in the dark with Empanadaville and we are SO glad we did. Our review is not based on policy as they wouldn’t have the policies they have if it wasn’t for...
$ $$$
4.40 (496 reviews)
4
Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina
Pizza restaurant
🫤 The pizza was alright, probably better than other places around here, but WOW the price is so…. Terrible.
$48 for this pathetic pepperoni pie, and a mid plain pie 💀😂😂 what a joke. Think I’ll stick to the best competitor aka Pizza Time, cause they dont skimp out on anything lol.
And if you wanna...
$$ $$
4.50 (270 reviews)
5
Fratelli’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Staff is very pleasant, the food is even better. The garlic knots had a great garlic to parm ratio. The dough was tender with everything they had. Just the perfect crispy bite, not that soggy floppy thing you get from other pizza places. The sauce is full of flavor, even better then mama Lisa's in m...
$ $$$
4.40 (257 reviews)
6
Pizza Time
Pizza restaurant
Basic local pizzeria chain offering specialty pies, plus carry-out & delivery deals.
$ $$$
4.20 (283 reviews)
7
Neighborhood Country Market
Convenience store
👍👍 Abdul, the owner of this place, is such a gem! He showed great hospitality as soon as we walked in the door and he takes such pride in his shop and his fried chicken recipe. Speaking of which, the fried chicken here...OMG! It was incredible! If you have the privilege of living near this place, do yo...
$$ $$
4.70 (61 reviews)
8
Anthony's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Local counter-serve chain that's a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats.
$ $$$
4.40 (85 reviews)
9
Handy Pantry
Convenience store
😐 I ordered some egg salad, when I got it home to eat it wasn't fresh. The eggs and mayonnaise were spoiled. I bought it back for refund or replacement and that was spoiled as well. Very disappointed
4.20 (103 reviews)
12
Good Friends
Bar
😠 Apparently people get jumped after leaving here and the owners will not call an ambulance! They will drive you somewhere else and then lie and claim their cameras don't work because they don't want to get sued for failing to provide proper security! So beware!!
$ $$$
4.00 (135 reviews)
13
Lindsor Torres
Off track betting shop
😠 My husband goes here and tells the bartenders to tell whoever calls that he’s not there . I had an emergency with my daughter and they said he wasn’t there . As passing in the ambulance to go to the hospital his van was there . Another time his mom needed to get a hold of him and they lied to her as...
$ $$$
4.20 (62 reviews)
14
Hero Haven Pizza & more
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Been going there since they opened,wonderful family.they now make Strathmore bagels,don't let the deli sign foolu they r the best bagels I had in the whole Suffolk county and I am very particular especially with the everything bagel
They r covered top to bottom,fabulous.PLEASE TRY THEM U WILL NEVER...
3.70 (288 reviews)
15
New Rooster Kitchen
Chinese restaurant
👍👍 Yummy Milk tea, wasn't sure about ordering from here but I was really craving some boba. Since there is nowhere near here that has some I gave in. Best decision I could've made. Everyone was friendly here, smelled delicious too. Can't wait to try their food too!!
$$ $$
3.50 (135 reviews)
17
China Star
Chinese restaurant
😐 I order Chinese 3 lunch specials and of course the one I got had Staples in the meal. I felt something sharp in my food I spit it out and sure enough there was staples in my food. I took it back with the paper towel I spit on. They asked me how the staples got in the food. Hello the plastic containe...
$$ $$
3.40 (154 reviews)
18
Handy Pantry
Convenience store
😠 I live local to this business & have on almost EVERY occasion had a terrible experience. Whether it’s the bottle machine or the customer service it’s been a total debacle. Recently upon my wife purchasing a cup of coffee, she was given change of a $20 and the $10 bill she was given was very dirty. N...
3.60 (48 reviews)
Cities near Mastic Beach
- Mastic (~4 km)
- Shirley (~5 km)
- Moriches (~5 km)
- Center Moriches (~5 km)
- East Moriches (~8 km)
- Bellport (~9 km)
- North Bellport (~9 km)
- Yaphank (~10 km)
- Remsenburg-Speonk (~12 km)
- Manorville (~12 km)
- East Patchogue (~13 km)
- Medford (~15 km)
- Patchogue (~15 km)
- Ridge (~15 km)
- Middle Island (~16 km)
- North Patchogue (~16 km)
Last updated: