Top rated Italian restaurants in Mastic, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Mastic

Experience the best that Mastic has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 20 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Mastic

Bernie's Family Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Best pizza and chicken parmigiana heros for literally miles, no competition, i can down half a pie in less then 10 minutes.

$$ $$

4.80 (206 reviews) (~1.62 km from centre)

La Volpe Restaurant & Anton Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Elevated & inviting eatery with Tuscan-style decor turning out Sicilian mains & wood-fired pizza.

$$ $$

4.60 (754 reviews) (~3.29 km from centre)

Onofrio's

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Been going here on and off for 38 years when I would go to my friends summer house in Mastic Beach and the pizza still tastes the same. Consistency is the secret to the delicious pizza pies. The many dishes they serve are also excellent.

$$ $$

4.60 (225 reviews) (~4.69 km from centre)

Cafe Castello

Italian restaurant

👍👍 They also have the best lemon pancakes around!

$$ $$

4.60 (179 reviews) (~9.61 km from centre)

La Margherita Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Spacious Italian eatery starring pizza from a wood-burning brick oven & familiar Italian dishes.

$$ $$

4.50 (1K reviews) (~9.59 km from centre)

Avino's Italian Table

Italian restaurant

Traditional, intimate option featuring Italian classics, creative martinis & a large array of wine.

$$ $$

4.50 (436 reviews) (~9.75 km from centre)

Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina

Pizza restaurant

🫤 The pizza was alright, probably better than other places around here, but WOW the price is so…. Terrible. $48 for this pathetic pepperoni pie, and a mid plain pie 💀😂😂 what a joke. Think I’ll stick to the best competitor aka Pizza Time, cause they dont skimp out on anything lol. And if you wanna...

$$ $$

4.50 (270 reviews) (~2.61 km from centre)

Mama Lisa Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Classic Italian cuisine & specialty pizzas are served in a modern dining room or to go.

$$ $$

4.40 (1.6K reviews) (~1.06 km from centre)

Fratelli’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Staff is very pleasant, the food is even better. The garlic knots had a great garlic to parm ratio. The dough was tender with everything they had. Just the perfect crispy bite, not that soggy floppy thing you get from other pizza places. The sauce is full of flavor, even better then mama Lisa's in m...

$ $$$

4.40 (257 reviews) (~4.53 km from centre)

Pennachio's

Pizza takeaway

😐 PLEASE accept this as constructive criticism, as I am only hoping it will help you improve. When you first opened, I came in personally to tell you how yours was the best pizza I had tasted in years! Literally brought tears to my eyes, it was SO good! But as time has gone by, it has slowly evolved i...

$$ $$

4.40 (213 reviews) (~8.33 km from centre)

Yaphank Community Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 This is the worst pizza I have ever eaten.. I bought 2 regular slices and 2 sodas.. the soda was expired from January 2nd..and the pizza was so mushy soft and not even hot from the oven with oil seeping out of both sides.. also the refrigerator with the pizzas inside were very dirty with smears all...

4.40 (157 reviews) (~7.43 km from centre)

Carlos Pizza Of Manorville

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 1st time here & will be back. Excellent & yummy food. Portions are big so had take homes 👍 for another meal. Nicely decorated. *Only negative would be if out of a product/dish let the staff know. I ordered a dessert, waiter had to come back that they didn't have part of the dessert (cookie). Staff...

$$ $$

4.30 (480 reviews) (~3.79 km from centre)

Original Michelangelo Pizzeria-Restaurant Eastport

Italian restaurant

😠 $20 for a regular pie? That’s ridiculous and overpriced for no reason. Their regular pie isn’t even worth the $20. Always comes out undercooked, super greasy and floppy. Place has been garbage for years. Everything overpriced and the staff doesn’t know how to help people when they walk in. What a sh...

$$ $$

4.30 (296 reviews) (~9.48 km from centre)

Brothers Four Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 Had a bad experience tonight. Called and spoke to owner and nothing was done. I will definitely not be returning and my workplace also will not be returning as customers. Blaming something on a person that I'm sure does not exist is wrong because you don't want to refund money and take the loss. I s...

$ $$$

4.30 (278 reviews) (~4.17 km from centre)

Sea Cove

Italian restaurant

Modest eatery serving pasta, pizza, familiar Italian entrees, steaks & burgers in a warm atmosphere.

$$ $$

4.20 (629 reviews) (~4.06 km from centre)

Alitalia

Pizza restaurant

😠 Worst customer service ever when they make multiple mistakes they blame the customer they never own up to their mistakes. The owner hates being there, and it clearly shows with the customer service. He doesn’t care if you stay or you go we were a customer for years very loyal, I had one issue spoke...

$$ $$

4.20 (176 reviews) (~3.52 km from centre)

Carlo's Pizza Shirley

Pizza restaurant

😠 This used to be one of my favorite pizza places. It is now run by a bunch of teenagers who care more about their phones then they do the customers. The pie I received today was undercooked and barely had any cheese. I also ordered a platter of spaghetti with tomato sauce and got spaghetti and meatb...

$$ $$

4.10 (863 reviews) (~5.35 km from centre)

Cafe Gia

Italian restaurant

Spacious mall eatery crafts classic & specialty pizzas plus Italian staples in bright, modern digs.

$$ $$

4.10 (670 reviews) (~9.52 km from centre)

Savarona's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Everyone is super nice and pizza is always fast and fresh. They even take special requests like a heart shaped pizza with a garlic bread crust for her 18th bday. I used to work there back in college and I've still been going here for years. Great place!

$$ $$

4.10 (153 reviews) (~1.59 km from centre)

Tommy's Pizzeria & Bubble Tea

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 New owner is SO nice!! I didn’t realize what time it was and called to order a pie, he said he was closing but would make it for me anyway. I insisted on him not making it since i was in Riverhead and wouldn’t be to him for a bit so i didn’t keep him waiting, he was so sweet and told me to come on d...

$$ $$

3.70 (277 reviews) (~2.24 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Mastic, United States