Top rated Restaurants in McKinleyville

Experience the best that McKinleyville has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 207 places from Restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories



Familia Café in Eureka image
1
Familia Café in Eureka
Cafe
👍👍 Beautiful cafe in historic hotel, great indoor seating and ambiance. Small batch pastries, local roasted coffee- awesome cappuccino, hot chocolate and lattes. Breakfast: granola parfaits, chilaquiles, sandwiches, toast; avocado, banana almond, mushroom and more; soup and salad. Great place to visit,...
4.90 (112 reviews) (~16.71 km from centre)
Mother's Cooking Experience image
2
Mother's Cooking Experience
Restaurant
👍👍 We traveled to Arcata for my birthday and to visit with our daughter who is a student at Cal Poly Humboldt. We decided to visit Mothers Cooking Experience to have brunch but also to support a black owned business. Once inside, we looked over the menu and ordered our meals at the counter. We found a...
$$ $$
4.90 (107 reviews) (~8.99 km from centre)
Alma's Mexican Food image
3
Alma's Mexican Food
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Alma has it DOWN! In town for work and stumbled across the food truck. If your traveling through or close. Take the turn and try it out! Limited hours. I wish they did breakfast burritos early morning for all the work crews!!!
$ $$$
4.90 (100 reviews) (~4.95 km from centre)
Big Island Kine image
4
Big Island Kine
Restaurant
4.90 (42 reviews) (~17.2 km from centre)
Cap's Food Shack image
5
Cap's Food Shack
Restaurant
👍👍 Fun atmosphere with music. Cool people running it. The picture doesn’t lie. This burger is awesome
4.90 (40 reviews) (~18.69 km from centre)
Renata's Crêperie image
6
Renata's Crêperie
French restaurant
Art lines the walls of this snug, brightly decorated cafe specializing in sweet & savory crepes.
$$ $$
4.80 (949 reviews) (~8.63 km from centre)
Larrupin' Cafe image
7
Larrupin' Cafe
Steak house
Upscale, enduring venue with eclectic decor & locally sourced New American dishes, plus beer & wine.
$$$$
4.80 (680 reviews) (~16.5 km from centre)
Papa Wheelies image
8
Papa Wheelies
Restaurant
👍👍 Wonderful food, beer, and hot sauce selection in an unassuming location! We got a plum sour from the local brewery, but the standout was the lobster tail mushroom Buffalo Bleu cheese "wings" which were absolutely drenched in an amazing sauce and accompanied by a surprising selection of ice cold, fla...
4.80 (237 reviews) (~0.84 km from centre)
Fiesta Cafe image
9
Fiesta Cafe
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 I don’t review often but let me tell you, Fiesta Cafe is so legit. So f’n good. I live in Sacramento and don’t get out here often but I was here 2/8/23 and absolutely loved every bite. I had a lot of food. The Pork Tamale with Chile Relleno with beans. I added rice and flour tortilla. I’m telling y...
$$ $$
4.80 (130 reviews) (~17.59 km from centre)
Island Delight image
10
Island Delight
Hawaiian restaurant
👍👍 Excellant Authentic local island food. Prepared island style. Greeted and served with "Aloha spirit". We will surely stop in when we visit Eureka in October. Get the sweet sour spareribs over rice.
4.80 (114 reviews) (~19.51 km from centre)
Tacos el gallo image
11
Tacos el gallo
Restaurant
👍👍 The best tacos so far! Fresh and delicious
4.80 (94 reviews) (~17.97 km from centre)
Nou Nou's image
12
Nou Nou's
Restaurant
👍👍 Amazing food, the rice is to die for. Very well priced for the portions. I will definitely go back again. Very friendly service.
4.80 (47 reviews) (~16.96 km from centre)
Low & Slow BBQ image
13
Low & Slow BBQ
Restaurant
👍👍 This was the first try for a meal at Low ‘n Slow BBQ and we were not expecting the amazing meal we had. The Burnt Ends were delicious and the Ribs were near perfection. We taste the Mac n cheese, baked beans, an both flavors of corn muffin. We did not go away disappointed. Left with lunch for the n...
4.80 (40 reviews) (~11.78 km from centre)
Los Bagels image
14
Los Bagels
Bagel shop
Rustic cafe offering house-baked bagels, breads & pastries, along with Mexican treats.
$ $$$
4.70 (792 reviews) (~8.51 km from centre)
Northtown Coffee image
15
Northtown Coffee
Cafe
👍👍 Amazing people here. So we couldn’t decide. Oracle dog through the arch says, the ‘Cosmic’. And so it was: cosmic. It had shrooms! Just kidding it was delicious and no we didn’t hallucinate the wonderful bathroom mural of Gaia holding the world tree. But I had the compulsion to buy a bunch of...
$$ $$
4.70 (467 reviews) (~8.11 km from centre)
McIntosh Farm Country Store image
16
McIntosh Farm Country Store
Breakfast restaurant
👍👍 You need to get here early and try their hand- made donuts. Thank me later. That and the mini man breakfast sandwich. You're welcome.
$$ $$
4.70 (456 reviews) (~4.97 km from centre)
Amigas Burritos Mexican Restaurant image
17
Amigas Burritos Mexican Restaurant
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Vegan friendly! I walked in and asked if they had vegan friendly options, and they walked me through modifications and what I could get. I got two bean n rice tacos w lettuce and the veggie salsa. They were good! Also the guac here is great. Love the decorations and the service was fast and friendly...
$ $$$
4.70 (380 reviews) (~17.05 km from centre)
Roman's Kitchen image
18
Roman's Kitchen
Restaurant
👍👍 Quaint, family-run business. All smiles and friendly customer service. Plenty of room for parking. Outdoor seating available. I got the Philly dip which was outstanding. I’d been out of the states for a while and haven’t had a good quality sandwich in close to two years. Let me tell you I could have...
$$ $$
4.70 (334 reviews) (~8.47 km from centre)
Headies Pizza and Pour image
19
Headies Pizza and Pour
Pizza restaurant
4.70 (291 reviews) (~13.17 km from centre)
Phatsy Kline's Parlor Lounge image
20
Phatsy Kline's Parlor Lounge
Restaurant
👍👍 I come here very regularly because they FOR SURE have the best drinks in town! I would also recommend anything on the menu because they will never disappoint given their constant innovation!!
4.70 (287 reviews) (~16.89 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories


Last updated:
( )