Top rated Italian restaurants in Mercer Island

Experience the best that Mercer Island has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 57 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



84 Yesler image
1
84 Yesler
New American restaurant
Creative local & global bites such as pasta, steak & seafood dishes are served at this cozy eatery.
4.80 (233 reviews) (~8.54 km from centre)
Salumi image
2
Salumi
Sandwich shop
Tiny storefront offering artisanal Italian cured meats in sandwiches & by the pound.
$$ $$
4.70 (1.2K reviews) (~8.26 km from centre)
Nine Pies Pizzeria image
3
Nine Pies Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
New York-style pizza, calzones, and pasta in a sleek space adjacent to the Nine Hats Wines tasting room.
$$ $$
4.70 (420 reviews) (~8.13 km from centre)
The Independent Pizzeria image
4
The Independent Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Cozy neighborhood pizzeria features wood-fired pies with creative toppings in a relaxed atmosphere.
$$ $$
4.70 (233 reviews) (~7.59 km from centre)
The Pink Door image
5
The Pink Door
Italian restaurant
Italian restaurant with cabaret shows and trapeze entertainment, plus terrace with Elliott Bay views.
$$$ $
4.60 (5.3K reviews) (~9.4 km from centre)
Spinasse image
6
Spinasse
Italian restaurant
Bustling, high-end Northern Italian restaurant in a cozy, rustic space with an open kitchen.
$$$ $
4.60 (1.2K reviews) (~7.79 km from centre)
Il Terrazzo Carmine image
7
Il Terrazzo Carmine
Italian restaurant
Upscale institution for Italian fine dining with an extensive wine list in an airy & refined space.
$$$ $
4.60 (795 reviews) (~8.39 km from centre)
Bar del Corso image
8
Bar del Corso
Italian restaurant
Modern, warm Italian eatery with small plates plus pizzas from a blue-tiled wood-burning oven.
$$ $$
4.60 (731 reviews) (~6.15 km from centre)
Pasta Casalinga image
9
Pasta Casalinga
Italian restaurant
Italian spot for handcrafted pastas & wine served in a petite space amidst the bustling market.
$$ $$
4.60 (702 reviews) (~9.14 km from centre)
Altura image
10
Altura
Italian restaurant
Elevated seasonal Italian cuisine with handmade pastas, tasting menus & wine pairing in a cozy room.
$$$$
4.60 (579 reviews) (~8.83 km from centre)
Thats Amore Italian Cafe image
11
Thats Amore Italian Cafe
Italian restaurant
Casual trattoria with views of the Seattle skyline serving pizza, pasta & other Italian fare
$$ $$
4.60 (446 reviews) (~5.08 km from centre)
Cornelly image
12
Cornelly
Pizza restaurant
Straightforward takeaway featuring pizzas, pasta dishes & salads, plus desserts.
$$ $$
4.60 (304 reviews) (~9.07 km from centre)
Mercato Stellina Pizzeria image
13
Mercato Stellina Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 5 stars for service, food and ambience. Their pizza is fantastic and the wine selection is impressive. Mercato Sterling is a small spot which makes the dining experience very intimate! Highly recommend for a nice lunch, date night, or dinner with family and friends.
$$ $$
4.60 (259 reviews) (~4.1 km from centre)
Sahara Pizza image
14
Sahara Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Basic pizzeria chain also offering a few pasta dishes in modest digs, plus takeout.
$$ $$
4.60 (179 reviews) (~3.88 km from centre)
Darkalino's image
15
Darkalino's
Italian restaurant
👍 Welcome to the neighborhood Darkalino’s - you had some pretty big shoes to fill replacing our beloved London Plane and I’m happy to report that you’re off to a good start. In a neighborhood awash with mediocre Italian food you’re certainly a step above. Good pasta, nice salad and great focaccia. I m...
$$ $$
4.60 (62 reviews) (~8.28 km from centre)
Assaggio Ristorante image
16
Assaggio Ristorante
Italian restaurant
Refined, but informal trattoria serves high-end Italian fare amid Renaissance-style murals.
$$$ $
4.50 (1.3K reviews) (~9.39 km from centre)
Due' Cucina - Capitol Hill image
17
Due' Cucina - Capitol Hill
Italian restaurant
Bright, relaxed cafe serving health-conscious, handmade pastas topped with seasonal sauces.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.2K reviews) (~8.64 km from centre)
Tutta Bella Neapolitan Pizzeria - Columbia City image
18
Tutta Bella Neapolitan Pizzeria - Columbia City
Pizza restaurant
Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas & other Italian fare served in a sleek space with a casual vibe.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.1K reviews) (~4.78 km from centre)
Carmine's image
19
Carmine's
Italian restaurant
Refined locale specializing in classic Italian dishes complemented by an extensive wine list.
$$$ $
4.50 (994 reviews) (~4.23 km from centre)
Mioposto Pizzeria image
20
Mioposto Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Pizzeria with Mediterranean small plates & thin-crust, wood-fired pies plus breakfast & cocktails.
$$ $$
4.50 (935 reviews) (~4.55 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )