Worst rated Thrift stores in Middle Island, United States to Avoid (Updated April, 2024)

Worst rated Thrift stores in Middle Island

Steer clear of these locations to ensure a positive experience in Middle Island. Our list highlights the least favorable places to help you make informed choices and enjoy your time in the city. This list contains 9 places from Thrift store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Middle Island

Society of St. Vincent de Paul

Thrift store

3.10 (119 reviews) (~63.64 km from centre)

Beacon's Closet Park Slope

Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing, shoes & accessories, including selections from top designers, in hip corner digs.

$ $$$

3.20 (326 reviews) (~90.52 km from centre)

Plato's Closet Hamden

Clothing store

Chain retailer buying & selling trendy secondhand clothing for teens & young adults.

3.20 (144 reviews) (~54.12 km from centre)

Browse Consignment

Thrift store

3.20 (12 reviews) (~91.21 km from centre)

Farmingdale Thrift Shop

Thrift store

😠 Don’t waste your time here. The store is junky, untidy and very old. There are no prices on anything I saw. The price is based on how the guy behind the counter feels that day I guess. That concerns me because the price is subjective. I was wearing a blue shirt, maybe he doesn’t like blue and gav...

3.30 (38 reviews) (~45.99 km from centre)

Angela's Vintage Boutique

Vintage clothing store

Small vintage boutique featuring refined looks for women, including dresses, furs, shoes & jewelry.

$$$ $

3.30 (29 reviews) (~90.4 km from centre)

Bellport Methodist Thrift Shop

Thrift store

😠 The only thing I really bothers me that they write the prices on the stuff like books, mugs , with sharpie, if u buy something nice n you would to use it as a gift the price is marked on it, I think they should have labels, n not write the price on the stuff, and they do over price, i pay 30.00 just...

3.30 (12 reviews) (~13.75 km from centre)

The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center

Thrift store

3.40 (51 reviews) (~14.12 km from centre)

Second Chance Thrift Shop

Thrift store

😠 My little sister and I went here a few months ago and the two women at the desk yelled at us for accidentally bumping into something - NOT EVEN KNOCKING IT OVER OR ANYTHING. Yelled at us that if it were to break we would pay for everything that fell off that little table. They continued to stare us...

3.40 (43 reviews) (~65.9 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Worst rated Thrift stores in Middle Island, United States