Best places in Middle Island
Discover the best places in Middle Island, curated using our unique algorithm blending 'Top Rated' and 'Most Reviewed' establishments. Uncover the city's gems and must-visit locales for an unforgettable experience. Please note that certain places categories are intentionally excluded to ensure a refined selection. Ratings are based from 27 places in the village.
Sort results by
Best Top rated Most reviewed Hidden gems Worst rated Recently discoveredSearch radius
Categories
1
Long Island
Island
Storied group of towns & resort areas including the Hamptons & Montauk with beaches, dining & shops.
4.50 (2K reviews)
2
Prosser Pines Nature Preserve
Park
👍👍 Really pretty location with amazing scenery. The pines are massive here. There were teepee structures bigger then I've seen before.
4.70 (280 reviews)
4
Shah’s Halal Food
Halal restaurant
👍👍 ⚡Lisa - Their mixing it up and doing it Right.The Greatest Customer Service! Love Them. Keep up the Great Work Halal!
- truly Lisa Lichelle ✨
⚡Lisa - They're so friendly, quick and efficient. Way to go Halal ! Check them out
- Lisa Lichelle ✨
$ $$$
4.70 (189 reviews)
6
Cathedral Pines County Park
Park
Parkland for hiking, mountain biking & camping, adjoining a white pine preserve.
4.40 (402 reviews)
7
Athens Diner
Diner
👍👍 Cute personal diner. Seated quickly, service was good. Food was served hot, made sure you had coffee. Clean place, clean restroom.
4.50 (239 reviews)
10
Strathmore Commons Shopping Mall
Shopping mall
👍👍 Hometown North shore shopping center with everything you need including dollar tree, grocery store and fast food. Well maintained, clean, easy to navigate parking lot.
4.30 (290 reviews)
11
AYCE Mongolian Grill
Mongolian barbecue restaurant
👍👍 Very laid back. You pick a bowl and put in your carbs, veggies and proteins along with a sauce,and bring to grill area. The grill master (?) then proceeds to grill up your food, plates it, and hands it back to you. AYCE within a 2 hour time limit.
All I can say is delish! Best part, tofu and Garde...
4.40 (174 reviews)
13
Middle Island Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 ⚡Lisa - UPDATE✨ Excellent Service. In & out immediately, always. Nice Aye! He said, why all the pictures. I said, cause Your the Best! - Lisa Lichelle ✨
⚡Lisa - Friendly quick service. Nice staff. Efficient. In & out always. Nice Aye. I got to try their pizza.
- Lisa Lichelle ✨
$$ $$
4.20 (361 reviews)
14
Bagels 101
Bagel shop
😠 Officially DONE with this place. Have been giving them chances for over 4 years and here is how it goes. There is a 85-95% chance of them getting your order wrong, even when you text it very simply and clearly to them. And I am not exaggerating. There have been maybe 2 times in the past 4+ years I h...
$ $$$
4.20 (322 reviews)
16
Lombardi's of middle island
Italian restaurant
Romantic neighborhood mainstay since 1977 offering traditional Italian dishes like pasta.
$$ $$
4.10 (291 reviews)
17
MELTology Bar & Grilled Cheese
Restaurant
👍👍 If you looking for a brunch spot with unlimited mimosas this is the place to go . I went for my birthday and had a good time . It's a fix menu for unlimited mimosas however you won't be disappointed.
$$ $$
4.10 (272 reviews)
19
McDonald's
Fast food restaurant
Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.
$ $$$
3.90 (734 reviews)
20
Uncle Ray's Kitchen
Chinese restaurant
😠 Ordered boneless spareribs with house fried rice. Halfway through the meal found a staple in the rice. And I liked this place but not any more. They should really allow you to give no stars.
4.10 (142 reviews)