3
Vecchitto's Italian Ice
Ice cream shop
Seasonally-open parlor featuring a rotating menu of Italian ice flavors, like watermelon & almond.
$ $$$
4.90 (334 reviews)
4
Bergen House
Brewery
👍👍 Awesome mead! I never had it before and it was great. Where have you been all my life! I don’t really like beer so this is the perfect alternative. Plenty of table place here! Friendly staff and a bunch of different games for your table to enjoy while you drink your mead. Reasonable prices too! De...
4.90 (85 reviews)
5
Breakwaters Cigar & Whiskey Lounge LLC
Cigar shop
👍👍 Rudolfo made everything enjoyable from the start. Super friendly and accommodating. We pulled into the parking lot and he was assisting and elderly gentleman (who was a customer of another store in the plaza, not a cigar customer).
Lounge is clean and spacious. Solid selection of cigars and prices....
4.90 (81 reviews)
6
Cigar Sessions
Cigar shop
👍👍 I stopped here on my way from New Jersey to home in South Carolina. I'm happy that the town of Middletown has an awesome venue like this. If you are local want a cool cigar bar to enjoy yourself, this seems like "The Place!" I met the owner, very nice, am extreme impressed by their selection of ci...
4.80 (167 reviews)
7
Forest City Brewing
Brewery
👍 This is a small brewery that has a nice selection of beer. We enjoyed their sours and IPAs. The bartender was super friendly! They also serve some food like pretzels, pizza, cookies and chips. They also have games. We really enjoyed island time and sweet Mary sour ale!
4.80 (98 reviews)
8
La Casa Mania Mexican Restaurant & Bar
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Don't sleep on this new little gem of Middletown!! First time tonight and they have gained a long time friend with us!! Amazing service, clean, fun atmosphere... Cute seating outside. Little bar....
We did take out and it was perfect 👌 thank you so much!! Can't wait to try other things ( I have a b...
4.80 (73 reviews)
10
OSA
Gastropub
Italian small plates, wine & whiskey in a striking contemporary space lined with backlit wood slats.
$$$ $
4.70 (281 reviews)
11
First State Brewing Company
Brewery
👍👍 We were driving from Lehigh Valley, PA to Cambridge, MD and made a halfway stop at First State for some brews and dinner! We were not disappointed! Shared the poutine (amazing!) and had the chicken sandwich and burger. The menu had many other options like tacos, cheesesteaks, wings. There is a huge...
4.70 (271 reviews)
12
Vault & Cellar
Restaurant
👍👍 First time here and we were impressed. Staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. Caitlin was our server, and she gave us some good recommendations. Menu is different than you are likely to find anywhere.
I had rabbit that was outstanding. Carrots and rice had subtle spices that merged perfectly w...
4.70 (244 reviews)
13
Harrie's Jailhouse
Bar
👍👍 This place is… AMAZING! What a great vibe and the best sandwiches ever. The drinks
are fantastic too! Put this on the top of your “must try” list. If you end up going do yourself a favor and order The Sanguiche - a big but surprisingly light sandwich bursting with all sorts of sweet and salty flavor...
$$ $$
4.70 (205 reviews)
14
West Central Wine
Wine bar
👍👍 We just moved here from Colorado and need to find our new "date night spot." We found it!!! Great atmosphere, dim lighting, the music is not loud (thank you!!), the wine selection is amazing, and the charcuterie board is perfect with its variety and deliciousness. Monica knew what she was doing when...
$$ $$
4.70 (165 reviews)
15
Kettering Health Middletown
Public medical center
👍👍 This was the best ER experience I've had. No
line of people waiting. I had other tests done
earlier in the week & still didn't know what was
wrong with me. Each person who dealt with me at Kettering was efficient & compassionate. They did all that they could to make me comfortable. And with 1 test,...
4.60 (1.3K reviews)
16
FigLeaf Brewing Company
Brewery
👍👍 Nice friendly atmosphere, open feel. I like it when you can sit and see the brewing tanks. Sometimes this can be a bit overwhelming, but not here; it's not so large, like some brewery/tap rooms, that you feel like you're in the great hall of a museum. No, this place somehow strikes a good balanc...
4.60 (427 reviews)
18
Ida's Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Italian & American meals like lasagna & pot pie served in a cozy space with simple, modern decor.
$$ $$
4.60 (299 reviews)
19
The Pub at Two Mile Corner
Bar
👍👍 Lil hole in the wall. Hands down best wings on the island. Food is amazing. Staff is awesome. Nice lil setup. Literally prices are a steal. I wish they would move with me to FL. I'm a wings connoisseur I've tried them all around... They have the best trust me.
$ $$$
4.60 (253 reviews)