Top rated Pizza restaurants in Middletown, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Pizza restaurants in Middletown

Experience the best that Middletown has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 54 places from Pizza restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Middletown

Chef's Cut Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Low-key pizza joint with counter service, tables & TV screens also serving sandwiches, wings & beer.

$ $$$

4.80 (550 reviews) (~3.91 km from centre)

Old School N.Y. Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Unpretentious strip-mall nook offering familiar thin-crust pies & slices in a casual setting.

$ $$$

4.70 (1K reviews) (~5.36 km from centre)

MozzaPi

Pizza restaurant

Bakery turning out bread, pastries & Neapolitan pizzas handcrafted with house-milled flour.

$$ $$

4.70 (534 reviews) (~2.09 km from centre)

Pizzaville

Pizza restaurant

$ $$$

4.70 (162 reviews) (~5.64 km from centre)

Craft House Pizza - Westport

Pizza restaurant

👍 First time here. We both ordered small pizza, I wanted pepperoni and mushrooms and add sausage to half. The waitress came over and said the manager said we don’t do just half on small pizzas but will do it this time. Then when we went to pay we had bought a 20.00 certificate off of WDRB morning show...

$$ $$

4.70 (72 reviews) (~5.37 km from centre)

Fat Jimmy’s Pizza

Buffet restaurant

Specialty pizzas, pastas & oven-baked subs offered in low-key quarters with a buffet.

$ $$$

4.60 (1K reviews) (~0.94 km from centre)

Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 I go here multiple times a week as I work right down the street, and it is always an amazing experience. The service and ownership are super friendly and personable, especially the waitress who works most weekdays during lunch. The pizza by the slice options are fantastic, especially the slices of t...

4.60 (217 reviews) (~8.94 km from centre)

Blaze Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Hip counter-serve pizzeria dishing up crispy, thin-crust pies made with creative toppings & sauces.

$ $$$

4.50 (1.7K reviews) (~7.7 km from centre)

Blaze Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Hip counter-serve pizzeria dishing up crispy, thin-crust pies made with creative toppings & sauces.

$ $$$

4.50 (1.1K reviews) (~2.92 km from centre)

Lou Lou Food & Drink

Restaurant

Casual, eclectic bar/cafe serving Southern food incorporating influences from New Orleans & Italy.

$$ $$

4.50 (1.1K reviews) (~9.43 km from centre)

Impellizzeri's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Local pizzeria chain serving pies, pasta & subs, plus beer & wine, in a relaxed setting.

$$ $$

4.50 (1K reviews) (~1.66 km from centre)

TWINSPIRE PIZZA LLC

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 My friend threw a birthday party for me there because I heard about the pizza and the beer on site/next-door. The pizza was fantastic. There was a great variety of delicious beers there also. What a great gym in the Lydon area.

$$ $$

4.50 (37 reviews) (~6.03 km from centre)