Top rated Trading card stores in Middletown, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Trading card stores in Middletown

Experience the best that Middletown has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 12 places from Trading card store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Middletown

Maziply Toys

Toy store

😠 4/29/23 - You would hope, in this day and age, that a company could take genuine criticism and learn from it. Instead, the owner makes up untrue claims about Schleich shortages (I called Schleich to confirm that there were shortages and they say this is statement is false) and closing to "clean wind...

4.80 (369 reviews) (~67.18 km from centre)

One Up Games

Video arcade

👍👍 We recently had my son's birthday here. They all had a great time and loved being able to play co-op or alone. The birthday package we reasonable and the fact that they close the play area for the whole party was awesome. My son and his friends are still talking about it. Thanks to Brian and the re...

4.80 (172 reviews) (~51.6 km from centre)

Grip It -n- Rip It

Trading card store

👍👍 Small shops but they always have stuff in stock, guys are nice hand helpful if you have any questions or even if you want to just have them look over anything you have to sell they always take the time to do so. They have some of the best singles around and I recently pulled these 2 cards from boxes...

4.80 (35 reviews) (~56.24 km from centre)

Untapped Games

Game store

👍👍 There’s not many local card places in the area so I’m glad this one’s so close by and they had such a wide variety of Pokemon card sets, boxes, and even pins. The staff there were all incredibly helpful even with an event going on I was helped quickly. Definitely recommend and will come back again....

4.70 (417 reviews) (~35.95 km from centre)

Reality A Games

Game store

😠 Buyer beware! This store has a shocking amount of counterfeit video games and systems. Went there at 12 pm (3/2/21) today and purchased Wario land and samurai shodown for the gameboy. The guy at the register did not give me a receipt for both items. Games were dirty and had to be cleaned with isopro...

4.60 (327 reviews) (~25.75 km from centre)

Darkwater Games

Game store

4.60 (142 reviews) (~66.91 km from centre)

The Wizards Duel

Hobby store

👍👍 Good place for gunpla, Tamiya model paint, and Yugioh. If you are into these hobbies and more go there. I didn't list all of stuff they sell because I left to not interupt the tournament going on. Therefore I didn't get to see everything they sell

4.50 (108 reviews) (~65.03 km from centre)

New England Picture

Picture frame shop

4.50 (48 reviews) (~78.41 km from centre)

Card Vault

Sports card store

4.40 (89 reviews) (~60.79 km from centre)

GameStop

Video game store

Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.

$$ $$

4.30 (466 reviews) (~33.06 km from centre)

Game X Change

Video game store

4.30 (344 reviews) (~67.49 km from centre)

Game King

Game store

👍👍 The store can be somewhat intimidating for new people, but everyone I’ve interacted with is super friendly! Overall a great place to spend time with friends playing card games you enjoy and make new ones playing those same games. Hopefully their products can come in faster as UPS issues halter their...

4.30 (222 reviews) (~20.55 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Trading card stores in Middletown, United States