1
Legacy Pizza & Bakery
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Let me say the pizza is top notch! The toppings they use are very good quality and you get lots!! Our server was a young man who was attentive and alert. It got really busy and he still was very attentive and apologized for a small wait. It’s been a long time since we have had such an on the ball se...
$$ $$
4.90 (249 reviews)
2
The Eagles Villa Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Pies, subs & Italian-American eats are on offer at this long-standing fixture in a vintage building.
$ $$$
4.70 (1.4K reviews)
3
Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap
American restaurant
😐 Self proclaimed foodie that over the years has become more and more critical with my food selections.
Was super excited to come here. The prospect of a tap room with both wood fired pizza and a Philly cheese steak was exciting. The atmosphere was great. Loved the seating, loved the big TV's and ba...
$$ $$
4.70 (250 reviews)
4
8th Street Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Staying in New Albany while attending the National Farm Machinery Show we decided to try 8th Street Pizza our first night here. Right off the bat I'll say they check all the boxes for a dining experience. First, their menu has a nice variety of options plus you can build your own pizza. Secondly, I...
$ $$$
4.60 (340 reviews)
6
Mimo's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍 The lobster ravioli tastes very amazing. I substituted the vodka sauce for alfredo sauce and it tasted so perfect. My husband said that his pizza tasted mediocre. The marinara sauce was extremely chunky and also didn't have much flavor. The service was very wonderful.
$$ $$
4.50 (340 reviews)
7
PARLOUR
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Our dinner here was fantastic! We stayed not far away for a basketball tournament and explored New Albany. The smoked wings were some of the best I've ever had. Great combination of smokiness and sauce. I also ordered a meatball sub. I never thought a meatball sub could be so unique and delicious. I...
$$ $$
4.40 (484 reviews)
8
Pizza King
Pizza restaurant
Family-friendly pizza, pasta & sub chain for delivery or eat-in, with beer & wine at some locales.
$$ $$
4.30 (1.6K reviews)
9
Arni's New Albany
Restaurant
Family-friendly regional chain eatery with a simple selection of pizza, pasta & Italian sandwiches.
$$ $$
4.30 (1.2K reviews)
10
Mellow Mushroom New Albany
Pizza restaurant
Funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas.
$$ $$
4.30 (1.1K reviews)
12
Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Carry-out chain featuring chicken wings, signature breadsticks & pizza tossed from housemade dough.
$ $$$
4.10 (933 reviews)
13
Sbarro
Pizza restaurant
Italian fast-food chain offering thin-crust pizza by the slice, plus pastas & salads.
$ $$$
4.10 (165 reviews)
14
Marco's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Counter-serve chain serving up a menu of specialty or custom pizzas for takeout or delivery.
$ $$$
3.90 (449 reviews)
15
Derby City Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😠 I have never rated a restaurant in my life, but that mystery meat chicken wing platter that they served was an absolute, horrible experience. Not to mention, they forgot to give me a fork. It seemed like they were warmed up in a microwave from frozen. The meat was dark, discolored, and slimy. Examp...
3.90 (75 reviews)
16
Pizza Hut
Pizza delivery
Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.
$ $$$
3.40 (507 reviews)
17
Papa Johns Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
$ $$$
3.30 (384 reviews)