1
Wheelys Farmstand Café
Restaurant
👍👍 This place was amazing. We're so glad we passed up IHOP for the waffles here. Not only was the food delicious, the open view was beautiful and the fella working made our day with his sheer good attitude. Great experience all around and can't wait to come back.
5.00 (38 reviews)
2
The Mercury Cafe & Teahouse
Vegetarian restaurant
👍👍 It's still amazing! Do yourself a favor and check this place out!
We stopped in while looking around Old New Castle on a Saturday morning. We were promptly able to get a seat and were helped by the owners Aaron and Dwayne. The Mercury Cafe and Teahouse is a very cool and eclectic place that checks...
$$ $$
4.90 (198 reviews)
3
VentiSei Wine Bar & Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍 We came here for dinner, got a bottle of sweet wine that we enjoyed. Got the zucchini flower appetizersthat we liked with the large fresh mint and basil . We both got a gondola, his a meatball and I a lazy lasagna and again loved the fresh mint and basil. I personally like more cheese, but the int...
4.90 (84 reviews)
7
Garrison Deli
Restaurant
Straightforward operation presenting a variety of sandwiches, plus salads, burgers & cold cuts.
4.80 (159 reviews)
8
EAT Bistro and Drinks
Restaurant
👍👍 If you haven't experienced the magic of Molly's food, Jeff's cocktails or the ambiance of Eat Bistro, don't wait. Go now. You won't be disappointed. Besides the amazing food and cocktails, the owners have not missed a beat with ambiance, making it very inviting and cozy. It's the little touches t...
$$ $$
4.80 (152 reviews)
10
Hogback Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Very chill and laid back place with lots of outdoor space. Loved the use of rubber ducky-like toys as the order identifiers. The cheesy garlic bread, pizza and calzones were delicious!
$$ $$
4.70 (415 reviews)
11
The Ladies of the Dukes
Italian restaurant
😠 First and foremost, we have eaten in this restaurant or picked-up take out for many years since I was young. The service and food have been steadily declining. Related to this incident, we purchased several meals for our family. When we got home I found the pictured dinner which was ice cold and...
$ $$$
4.70 (414 reviews)
12
Mamma Gina Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Best pizza, thin or thick, delicious! They fill with plenty of toppings that you request. You don’t question skimping of the toppings on their pizza because there is plenty. See my picture, we ordered a large pizza with 1/2 sausage & Fresh green peppers, and 1/2 White veggie w/Broccoli & Ricotta. Th...
$$ $$
4.70 (393 reviews)
13
The Confluence
Restaurant
👍👍 Attended a Baby shower here, it was my 1st time to visit The Confluence Community Coffee Shop & Eatery. It is a wonderful space for a party! The food was DELICIOUS! The Harvest turkey wrap was the BEST wrap I've ever eaten. Every worker presented a smile and I most definitely want to frequent this l...
$ $$$
4.70 (248 reviews)
14
New Castle Tavern
Restaurant
👍👍 *Overal experience- The place was a first time try. It was overly impressive. Big on inside with great family atmoshpere. Waitress was amazing.
*Quality and selection of food- Amazing food you expect from a more high end place with very expensive tastes
*Pricing- Very Reasonable
*Cleanliness-...
$$ $$
4.70 (122 reviews)
16
Jessop's Tavern
Traditional American restaurant
Casual pub in a circa-1724 building with Colonial fare features servers in period costumes.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.9K reviews)
17
Park Restaurant
American restaurant
👍👍 If you leave here hungry it's your own fault.
Very tasty, probably the best breaded mushrooms I've had in a long time. Breaded Tenderloin was amazing, bug enough for 2, came with 2 buns.
$ $$$
4.60 (1.7K reviews)
18
Hazel's Restaurant
Restaurant
👍👍 Very good breakfast. We were seated very quickly and had our drinks in a matter of seconds it seemed. We ordered and our food came out very quickly also. We were all very happy with our meals.
$ $$$
4.60 (842 reviews)
19
Mary's Restaurant & Bakery
Middle Eastern restaurant
Family-run spot offering Middle Eastern salads, sandwiches & platters in a laid-back atmosphere.
$ $$$
4.60 (774 reviews)
20
Pizza Man's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍 I love this place! One of the best pizza in new castle. My usual is the chicken, bacon, ranch pizza. I hold the ranch and have them put BBQ on it instead. It's always cool to perfection. They are also updating the restaurant which is really nice to see!
$ $$$
4.60 (411 reviews)