Top rated Sports card stores in New Haven, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Sports card stores in New Haven

Experience the best that New Haven has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 48 places from Sports card store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New Haven

ACSB - American Coin, Stamp & Bullion Inc

Coin dealer

😠 Buyers beware. I purchased a coin here which I was told had a unique tint to it. I paid spot price for silver plus a decent premium. Long story short, I went to sell the coin I purchased from here probably a year ago. Turns out it was made of bronze. Zero silver content at all. This place will take...

5.00 (214 reviews) (~88.9 km from centre)

KC's Gold and Collectibles

Coin dealer

5.00 (127 reviews) (~46.38 km from centre)

Big Pack Hobby Shop

Trading card store

5.00 (58 reviews) (~106.19 km from centre)

All Vintage Cards

Sports card store

5.00 (48 reviews) (~196.87 km from centre)

Piece of the Game

Sports card store

4.90 (55 reviews) (~88.57 km from centre)

Long Island Sports Cards Inc

Sports card store

4.90 (53 reviews) (~85.13 km from centre)

Sawyer's Sports Cards

Sports card store

👍👍 Stopped by this store while I was in town for work. Very well put together store with nice staff. I thought the prices on most products were very accurate and fair. Would love to be able to support you guys from NJ via an online store of sorts. Keep up the great work!

4.90 (51 reviews) (~149.43 km from centre)

Hall Of Fame Of Leominster

Sports card store

👍👍 First time customer and I was blown away by the kindness. My oldest son (7) is really into Pokémon cards right now. He saved up his allowance and I brought him into this store to buy some packs of Pokémon cards. The gentleman at the counter was super nice and very patient with my son as he picked ou...

4.90 (45 reviews) (~167.47 km from centre)

Revolution Records

Record store

4.90 (43 reviews) (~57.04 km from centre)

Filthbomb Breaks - Sports and Trading Cards Store

Sports card store

👍👍 Awesome spot. Sam helped me and was great. Dope selection

4.80 (153 reviews) (~76.86 km from centre)

Finnigan's Sportscards

Sports card store

👍👍 Love going here with my son and ripping packs and getting boxes. You can chill out and make a morning or afternoon of it. Alot of awesome choices. Jeff is the man!

4.80 (114 reviews) (~173.67 km from centre)

Upper Echelon

Shoe store

4.80 (85 reviews) (~247.43 km from centre)

Super Sport Cards

Sports card store

4.80 (68 reviews) (~57.52 km from centre)

The Card Capital

Sports card store

4.80 (63 reviews) (~238.24 km from centre)

JB'S Trading Card Co.

Sports card store

4.80 (39 reviews) (~230.17 km from centre)

Kryptic Collections

Trading card store

👍👍 The staff are very friendly and helpful. The store was clean and there is plenty of space to hangout and play games.

4.80 (36 reviews) (~227 km from centre)

That's Entertainment

Comic book store

4.70 (1.9K reviews) (~140.49 km from centre)

S&B Sports Collectibles

Sports card store

4.70 (236 reviews) (~228.9 km from centre)

SkyBox Trading Cards & Collectibles

Trading card store

👍👍 Took my 8 yr old here for pokemon cards. He was completely overwhelmed with the amount of product they have. What impressed me was the staff. They were all very nice and patient with all the customers and their questions. They took the time with kids to work out the best deals for their budgets and...

4.70 (213 reviews) (~44.25 km from centre)

Fearless Cards Toys & Collectibles

Sports card store

4.70 (59 reviews) (~72.44 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Sports card stores in New Haven, United States