Top rated Pizza restaurants in Nutley, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Pizza restaurants in Nutley

Experience the best that Nutley has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 84 places from Pizza restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Nutley

Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Dined in tonight with my husband and loved everything! From the moment you walk in you are welcomed with attentive and friendly staff. The appetizers were great, the Margerita and Bianca e Verde pizzas were *chef’s kiss* and dessert is a must! They have great offerings I have not seen in any other p...

4.90 (186 reviews) (~0.55 km from centre)

Little Pizza Heaven

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Unbelievably-delicious! I was not expecting such GREAT pizza. I'm from Brooklyn and NY and am usually not that impressed with the pizza around here, but WOW! We ordered the regular pie and the Margarita; both are excellent. I was blown away at how fantastic, not only the sauce is (which is well-bal...

$ $$$

4.90 (38 reviews) (~4.69 km from centre)

Bivio Pizza Napoletana

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Over the past 15 years, of all the pizza places I have been to in NJ and NYC, this is by far the best. This is precision pizza making from every aspect. Not only is the pizza great, but Tomaso (the owner) is so personable and always has a smile on his face. Try to make a reservation 1 week ahead as...

4.80 (182 reviews) (~4.18 km from centre)

Teglia Pizza Bar

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 So Montclair is known for good pizza but I just discovered the cream of the crop!! Teglia is a small spot that just opened on Bloomfield Ave. and it's a MUST TRY!! I went in just after 4pm and met the owner/executive chef Joe. We didn't order online so we got a chance to chat with him as he hand...

$$ $$

4.80 (145 reviews) (~4.92 km from centre)

Memo's Pizzeria & Grill

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Best pizza in the area. Wings are incredible! I mean just look at this pie, there is no where else we go for pizza and wings. The owner and his wife are so hospitable and kind. Please support this business!

$$ $$

4.80 (106 reviews) (~2.89 km from centre)

The Lighthouse Cafe

Kosher restaurant

👍👍 We used Lighthouse Cafe to cater our company event, and we couldn't have been happier with the experience. The food was delicious and everyone enjoyed.

$ $$$

4.70 (547 reviews) (~3.05 km from centre)

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Ordered from here while visiting the area for business. I had it delivered using GrubHub but the order came fast and was hot on delivery. The pizza was authentic traditional New York Style and was amazing. I will order again when I'm back in town. Please hit the Like Button if this was helpful.

$$ $$

4.70 (456 reviews) (~4.18 km from centre)

Alberto's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Argentinian restaurant

👍👍 My mother and I went for lunch around noon during the week. It wasn't busy and we ordered a veggie pizza. It was delicious and crispy like we wanted. For dessert we got the tres leches cake which was so good. The wait time was very long. Took about 50 minutes from the time we ordered for the pizza t...

$$ $$

4.70 (348 reviews) (~2.97 km from centre)

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 We just stopped in here after attending a funeral. We're from Philly. Not realizing that this location is take out, the staff cleaned off a table, complete with adding a centerpiece of mums, and proceeded to make us feel so welcome. The food was delicious. We had sandwiches, fries and a slice of...

$$ $$

4.70 (144 reviews) (~4.24 km from centre)

Tino's Artisan Pizza Co.

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Great pizza place with vegan options. We ordered pepperoni pizza and the chicken bites. It was fresh, and tasted great. The service is awesome too.

$$ $$

4.70 (63 reviews) (~4.6 km from centre)

Michael's Roscommon House

Restaurant

Family-owned sports tavern with many TVs, a pub menu in the dining room, separate bar & pool table.

$$ $$

4.60 (862 reviews) (~2.37 km from centre)

Queen Margherita Trattoria

Italian restaurant

Quaint & cozy BYOB eatery dishing up traditional red-sauce Italian meals in a relaxed atmosphere.

$$ $$

4.60 (857 reviews) (~1.61 km from centre)

Blue Steel Pizza Company

New American restaurant

Dark eatery with a secret bar crafting upscale Detroit-style pizzas, pasta & traditional entrees.

4.60 (639 reviews) (~4.67 km from centre)

Taste of Tuscany - Clifton NJ

Italian restaurant

👍 Well exceeded my expectations! We got the chicken vodka pie and it was fantastic. The picture you see is how it comes normal - this wasn't extra chicken. A very generous portion of protein. The crust was great and crispy (even stayed good when we reheated a few pieces the next day). The taste of the...

$ $$$

4.60 (593 reviews) (~2.15 km from centre)

Jerusalem Pizza Falafel

Pizza restaurant

Basic kosher joint with booths offering pizzas, pastas & pita sandwiches, along with a salad bar.

$ $$$

4.60 (537 reviews) (~3.92 km from centre)

Song E Napule - Rutherford

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 The best Neopolitan pizza I’ve found outside of Napoli, and I’ve tried them all. All food was delicious. Decor was fantastic, with essentially everything being made in Italy.

$$ $$

4.60 (381 reviews) (~4.63 km from centre)

La Venere Ristorante

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 The food here is totally amazing. It is Italian food at a very high level.The restaurant is relatively small; but the food is off the hook delicious. We had Brazilian sea bass, crab cakes, prosciouto, sausage, mashed potatos, antipasto, salads. So much delicious food for 8 people you were sorry you...

$$ $$

4.60 (376 reviews) (~4.6 km from centre)

Brick & Dough

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 My best friend and I visited Brick + Dough for lunch and we genuinely enjoyed our time here. Best garlic knots we've ever had, they were fluffy, airy, not super garlicy and soft. The margarita pizza and the buffalo chicken pizza were very good they weren't super black on the bottom like you'd find i...

4.60 (319 reviews) (~4.36 km from centre)

Tony's Pizza Pasta Grill

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Let me start off by saying this picture doesn't do justice as to how delicious these lemon garlic wings are lip smacking good. Tony the owner of this place also has may other dishes that are just as good. What makes this place great is his food and the service that goes along with it. Tony has also...

$$ $$

4.60 (284 reviews) (~4.31 km from centre)

Italia Pizza

Pizza restaurant

$$ $$

4.60 (279 reviews) (~4.57 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Pizza restaurants in Nutley, United States