Best places in Oyster Bay

Discover the best places in Oyster Bay, curated using our unique algorithm blending 'Top Rated' and 'Most Reviewed' establishments. Uncover the city's gems and must-visit locales for an unforgettable experience. Please note that certain places categories are intentionally excluded to ensure a refined selection. Ratings are based from 52 places in the city.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Planting Fields Arboretum State Historic Park image
1
Planting Fields Arboretum State Historic Park
Arboretum
Greenhouses, gardens & summer concerts on a 409-acre estate with an original Tudor Revival mansion.
4.80 (2.3K reviews) (~1.94 km from centre)
Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Park image
2
Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Park
Park
Bayside park with athletic fields & courts, playgrounds, boat ramps & a beach on Oyster Bay Harbor.
4.60 (1.6K reviews) (~0.61 km from centre)
Beast Martial Arts & Fitness of Oyster Bay image
3
Beast Martial Arts & Fitness of Oyster Bay
Martial arts school
👍👍 Oyster Bay Kickboxing is unlike any other gym or workout facility I’ve been a part of. The staff is COMPLETELY transparent in regard to membership fees and there are absolutely NO hidden fees (unlike many other gyms I’ve been a part of). This has been such a relief, as I have vowed to CLOSELY read A...
5.00 (137 reviews) (~0.78 km from centre)
N.T. Designs image
4
N.T. Designs
Florist
5.00 (112 reviews) (~0.67 km from centre)
Bonanza Stand of Oyster Bay image
5
Bonanza Stand of Oyster Bay
Hot dog stand
A lemon-ice legend for over a century, this little shack scoops dozens of flavors plus light bites.
$ $$$
4.60 (271 reviews) (~0.28 km from centre)
Heritage Oyster Bay (formerly Norwich Gate Luxury Rentals) image
6
Heritage Oyster Bay (formerly Norwich Gate Luxury Rentals)
Apartment rental agency
👍👍 David is fantastic. He is super friendly, detailed, and answered all of my questions. 10/10 - thank you, David! 😊 Update as of 7/19 - David came back for another service request and he was able to quickly and efficiently fix my issue. He is such a pleasure to work with. Thank s again!
4.80 (144 reviews) (~1.91 km from centre)
Home Sweet Home Cafe image
7
Home Sweet Home Cafe
Chilean restaurant
👍👍 I’ve been to a lot of delis/cafes in Long Island and this is by far the best one. The food has a rich and flavorful taste for even the most basic orders. I don’t know how they do it but keep it. This is a great spot!
$ $$$
4.70 (177 reviews) (~0.17 km from centre)
20th Century Cycles image
8
20th Century Cycles
Motorcycle shop
👍👍 Beautiful collection of bikes and well worth a walk around if you're in the area. I hadn't read up much on the place before taking a stroll through and was made to feel very welcome. There's no entrance fee and not much in the way of souvenirs (a few baseball caps and t-shirts). I saw one guy cleani...
4.90 (113 reviews) (~0.26 km from centre)
Wild Honey image
9
Wild Honey
American restaurant
Creative takes on New American fare served by candlelight in cozy digs, plus sidewalk seating.
$$ $$
4.50 (335 reviews) (~0.04 km from centre)
Southdown Coffee - Oyster Bay image
10
Southdown Coffee - Oyster Bay
Coffee shop
👍👍 A cute and classic cafe in a quaint seaside town. It’s the right blend of modern and modest, crisp and clean, and extremely welcoming. It’s a somewhat small U-shaped shop, with one booth and a long bench with four small tables and extra chairs, so seating is a little limited. Takeout is great, but...
$$ $$
4.60 (214 reviews) (~0.12 km from centre)
Taby's Burger House image
11
Taby's Burger House
Hamburger restaurant
Longtime storefront spot serving American bites for breakfast, lunch & dinner in old-fashioned digs.
$$ $$
4.40 (551 reviews) (~0.08 km from centre)
Raynham Hall Museum image
12
Raynham Hall Museum
Historical place museum
Former home of George Washington’s intelligence operative Robert Townsend, with preserved interiors.
4.90 (95 reviews) (~0.12 km from centre)
Autentico image
13
Autentico
Italian restaurant
4.60 (151 reviews) (~0.1 km from centre)
Oyster Bay Brewing Company image
14
Oyster Bay Brewing Company
Brewery
😠 Honestly, the worst experience I have had in Long Island. The person behind the bar started off by singling out who in the group needs to take out their license to be carded. Quite offensive, my friend was singled out as the only one that did not need to be carded out of the group. We are all within...
4.50 (197 reviews) (~0.1 km from centre)
The Homestead image
15
The Homestead
American restaurant
Familiar American pub grub & a full bar in a historic space with live music nights.
$$ $$
4.40 (289 reviews) (~0.04 km from centre)
Mama Mia’s Pizza & Pasta (Formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay) image
16
Mama Mia’s Pizza & Pasta (Formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay)
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 We got their menu in the mail and decided that since tomorrow it’s Thanksgiving and we’ve been cooking all day, let’s try take out. We usually order from Mario’s but decided to try out this “new” joint. The delivery guy was very warm and professional, the food was heavenly, perfect taste and tempera...
$ $$$
4.50 (190 reviews) (~0.76 km from centre)
Verizon image
17
Verizon
Cell phone store
👍👍 Drop T-Mobile immediately and go to the Oyster Bay Verizon store!! I switched service due to the incompetency and bad service from T-Mobile. The gentlemen at this Verizon store are knowledgeable, educated and professional. They spent a lot of time with me getting out of my old service and onto Veri...
4.60 (136 reviews) (~1.56 km from centre)
Cafe Al Dente image
18
Cafe Al Dente
Italian restaurant
$$ $$
4.50 (170 reviews) (~0.1 km from centre)
Del's Bar & Grill image
19
Del's Bar & Grill
Bar & grill
👍👍 Cool bar. Cold beer. Tasty burgers. Bartender was friendly I think he name was Laura. Met some friends and a some appetizers, burgers and beers. Some people came in to watch the Islander game. Nice crowd. Would go back. Food was all delicious. Tried the wings and the Potato skins as an app. I believ...
$$ $$
4.50 (153 reviews) (~1.24 km from centre)
Sweet Tomato image
20
Sweet Tomato
Restaurant
Quaint New American cafe serving breakfast, sandwiches, salads & more amid a display of student art.
$ $$$
4.40 (173 reviews) (~0.26 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )