Top rated Pie shops in Plum, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Pie shops in Plum

Experience the best that Plum has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 18 places from Pie shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Plum

Art's Bakery

Bakery

$ $$$

4.80 (596 reviews) (~178.74 km from centre)

Portage Pie

Pie shop

👍👍 Great pies! Just bought their strawberry pie. It's pretty good! Freshly made. Just come prepared. It's cash or check only and if your looking for something specific then call and order ahead. It's literally a tiny hallway to pick up pie orders. They have some already made but selection is limited. S...

$$ $$

4.80 (165 reviews) (~203.16 km from centre)

Burkholder's Baked Goods

Bakery

$ $$$

4.80 (123 reviews) (~206.42 km from centre)

Hershberger's Farm and Bakery

Bakery

Charming stop with housebaked Amish goods, crafts, seasonal produce & a petting zoo.

$ $$$

4.70 (3.5K reviews) (~175.36 km from centre)

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

Counter-serve chain where all of the ice cream selections are made fresh on-site every day.

$ $$$

4.70 (425 reviews) (~25.81 km from centre)

Mama Jo Homestyle Pies

Pie shop

4.70 (357 reviews) (~229.78 km from centre)

Ann's Pastry Shop

Bakery

👍👍 Nice baked goods. They did custom donut holes for a birthday party. And their pepperoni rolls are the best I've had.

$ $$$

4.70 (356 reviews) (~176.69 km from centre)

Loudounberry

Farmers' market

😐 Loudounberry is a small market on the side of the road specializing in baked goods and produce. We got a pecan pie, and the pie was good. Just in terms of the pie I rate a 8/10. The reason I give the overall review a 3 stars is because the staff don't wear masks at all. They then also handle credits...

4.70 (111 reviews) (~237.65 km from centre)

Graeter's Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

Longtime ice cream parlor chain serving small-batch scoops, plus signature sundaes & frozen drinks.

$$ $$

4.60 (190 reviews) (~28.54 km from centre)

Downtown Bakery

Bakery

$ $$$

4.50 (284 reviews) (~75 km from centre)

The Pie Place

Bakery

🫤 I struggle with how I feel about the Pie Place. Why? The inconsistency of their pies--and I've probably tried them all over the years. I can buy the same pie on multiple occasions & it's never the same. I'm sometimes disappointed by a pie I loved before. I adore their cream pies--lemon meringue & c...

$$ $$

4.50 (171 reviews) (~30.72 km from centre)

Graeter's Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

Longtime ice cream parlor chain serving small-batch scoops, plus signature sundaes & frozen drinks.

$$ $$

4.50 (103 reviews) (~213.23 km from centre)

Mansfield Family Restaurant- Southside

American restaurant

👍 First time here from out of town but work in the area on occasions as my office is near by. Wonderful fast friendly attentive service love the old school dinner feel and nostalgic decor very large give me a selection highly recommend this restaurant establishment for all your dining needs.

$ $$$

4.40 (1.3K reviews) (~234.76 km from centre)

Mansfield Family Restaurant - Westside

Family restaurant

👍👍 Line out the door the place was so packed but it thankfully didn’t take long to grab a booth and be treated to some down home Mansfield hospitality. This small town family restaurant feels like home and the food was exactly what you’d expect. Got a burger on Texas toast and it was topped by some fan...

$ $$$

4.40 (1.3K reviews) (~238.5 km from centre)

Graeter's Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

Longtime ice cream parlor chain serving small-batch scoops, plus signature sundaes & frozen drinks.

$$ $$

4.40 (219 reviews) (~180.34 km from centre)

Bakers Square

Family restaurant

Easygoing eatery & bakery chain serving up all-day comfort food & signature pies.

$$ $$

4.20 (1.3K reviews) (~196.59 km from centre)

Bakers Square

Family restaurant

Easygoing eatery & bakery chain serving up all-day comfort food & signature pies.

$$ $$

4.20 (958 reviews) (~186.84 km from centre)

The Daily Pressed

Bar

👍👍 Excellent cocktails and friendly staff! The interior is super swanky and their salads are superb. House-made dressing is *chef’s kiss*. Definitely recommend.

$ $$$

4.20 (109 reviews) (~162.37 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Pie shops in Plum, United States