Top rated Ice cream shops in Sarasota

Experience the best that Sarasota has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 53 places from Ice cream shop category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Made In Rome Organic Gelato image
1
Made In Rome Organic Gelato
Ice cream shop
Small, casual counter-serve stop scooping handcrafted Italian gelato with creative toppings.
$ $$$
4.90 (877 reviews) (~7.53 km from centre)
Jake's Ice Cream on Siesta Key image
2
Jake's Ice Cream on Siesta Key
Ice cream shop
👍👍 We decided to make a trip to Siesta Key Beach and it was beautiful! After our day in the sun, my daughters wanted ice cream. I looked up local ice cream shops in the area and came across Jake’s. It was delicious! It’s homemade and they have the option to try the various flavors. They top off your s...
4.90 (551 reviews) (~9.6 km from centre)
American Honey Creamery and Coffee Co. image
3
American Honey Creamery and Coffee Co.
Ice cream shop
👍👍 I love this place! Their specialty coffees are amazing! I highly recommend the Wild Flower Latte, Cowboy cookie latte and the American honey cold brew to name a few. My friend also really enjoys their ice cream! It’s definitely a must place to visit when I’m in town from Ohio!
4.90 (435 reviews) (~29.31 km from centre)
Main Street Creamery image
4
Main Street Creamery
Ice cream shop
👍👍 A MUST TRY!!!!! If you’re looking for a deliciously creamy non dairy ice cream, this should be #1 option if you’re in the Sarasota area. I ordered the peanut butter brownie IS THE BEST FLAVOR of peanut butter I’ve tried, which is the flavor they’re are winners for nationwide. To find a creamery w...
$$ $$
4.90 (328 reviews) (~1.24 km from centre)
Crisp Waffle Company image
5
Crisp Waffle Company
Restaurant
👍👍 So friendly, even though it's right on St. Armand's, it's very reasonabley priced. And literally the best ice cream and waffle I've ever had!! The flavors were so rich, portion size was huge, lots of options for fancy toppings.
4.90 (277 reviews) (~4.92 km from centre)
Kurtos Chimney Cake & Bread image
6
Kurtos Chimney Cake & Bread
Sandwich shop
👍👍 I love chimney cake, and in this store you can pick from sweet and savory also. I’m very “Hungarian” so I had the cheese chimney with teli salami ,hard boiled eggs and pickles ! My favorite! I was full all day long! The hot dog chimney also crazy delicious and of course for the sweet tooth we grab a...
$$ $$
4.90 (160 reviews) (~1.3 km from centre)
AMI Beach Hut image
7
AMI Beach Hut
Ice cream shop
4.90 (39 reviews) (~29.16 km from centre)
Detwiler's Farm Market image
8
Detwiler's Farm Market
Grocery store
4.80 (5.9K reviews) (~6.19 km from centre)
Detwiler's Farm Market image
9
Detwiler's Farm Market
Grocery store
4.80 (3.5K reviews) (~20.74 km from centre)
Orange Octopus image
10
Orange Octopus
Ice cream shop
Colorful, family-owned shop selling ice cream & milkshakes, plus hot & cold coffee drinks.
$ $$$
4.80 (857 reviews) (~9.47 km from centre)
Settimi's Gelato image
11
Settimi's Gelato
Ice cream shop
👍👍 Great smooth flavors. Staff is very kind and they offer sample products to choose the correct mix.
4.80 (557 reviews) (~5.06 km from centre)
Gelato-go Sarasota image
12
Gelato-go Sarasota
Ice cream shop
👍👍 Wonderful gelato! Passion fruit sorbet and honey gelato were both amazing and would highly recommend Gelato-go for adventurous and more reserved palettes. Plenty of chocolate and vanilla choices for the less adventuresome.
$$ $$
4.80 (538 reviews) (~0.79 km from centre)
Gelato-go Bakery Sarasota image
13
Gelato-go Bakery Sarasota
Ice cream shop
👍👍 I’ve been here a few times this month and there is no place like this, I always try every gelato flavor but now I bought a smoothie made with natural orange juice just at the moment. This is a very good option for many people looking for something healthy in the nearby area. Recomendado! Is always...
$$ $$
4.80 (122 reviews) (~5.13 km from centre)
Gelato-go Anna Maria Island image
14
Gelato-go Anna Maria Island
Ice cream shop
👍👍 Stopped in to pick up a couple of Gelatos. The shop is brand new and super clean. The servers were extremely nice . The shop had a nice variety of flavors, coffee and pastries. The gelato is very creamy and tasty. I would visit the shop again.
$$ $$
4.80 (60 reviews) (~21.78 km from centre)
Jeremiah's Italian Ice image
15
Jeremiah's Italian Ice
Ice cream shop
Counter-serve stand with frozen treats, including soft-serve cones, ices & gelati in many flavors.
$ $$$
4.70 (866 reviews) (~18.46 km from centre)
Ciao Gelato image
16
Ciao Gelato
Ice cream shop
$$ $$
4.70 (655 reviews) (~27.58 km from centre)
Small Town Creamery image
17
Small Town Creamery
Ice cream shop
$ $$$
4.70 (506 reviews) (~26.24 km from centre)
Sweetberries Frozen Custard & Eatery image
18
Sweetberries Frozen Custard & Eatery
Sandwich shop
👍👍 We heard about the incredible dessert 🍨 so we stopped by to check it out. We ordered and split a hot fudge sundae 🍨 😋 it rocked!!! Thank goodness we ordered a small, it was enormous, we had to bring some home. The service and workers were very positive and polite 😀. We will return.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.3K reviews) (~19.24 km from centre)
Two Scoops image
19
Two Scoops
Dessert shop
$$ $$
4.60 (1.1K reviews) (~29.44 km from centre)
Olaf's Siesta Village image
20
Olaf's Siesta Village
Ice cream shop
Small spot with sidewalk benches offering homemade ice cream in waffle cones & a variety of fudge.
$$ $$
4.60 (1K reviews) (~7.53 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Sarasota

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )