Most reviewed Bagel shops in Setauket, United States to visit (Updated April, 2024)

Most reviewed Bagel shops in Setauket

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Setauket through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 27 places from Bagel shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Setauket

Desiree's Bagel Co.

Bagel shop

👍👍 Delicious bagels and pastries at this bagel place!! Amazing breakfast sandwiches!! Gets busy busy but worth the wait! :) super friendly staff!!!

$$ $$

4.50 (601 reviews) (~9.56 km from centre)

Bagel Cafe of Stony Brook

Bagel shop

😠 Today I stopped in to get a sandwich. Ham, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, and Mayo on a roll. The store was not busy however the employees all seemed disgruntled. I took my sandwich with me and once i opened it I was extremely disappointed. My sandwich had 1 slice of ham and 1 slice of cheese. I have neve...

$ $$$

3.90 (570 reviews) (~6.74 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

4.20 (482 reviews) (~9.5 km from centre)

Cella Bagels & Grill

Bagel shop

👍👍 When we visit my sister in Long Island, we always get lunch here on our first day, breakfast our second day and bagels for our trip home the day before we leave. Their bagels are consistently wonderful, and my husband loves their mac salad. The employees are friendly and often remember us.

$ $$$

4.30 (417 reviews) (~9.76 km from centre)

Bagel Express

Bagel shop

😠 1.95 a bagel? What am I even witnessing? They taste like store bought bagels and you can’t even see them prior to buying. Bacon egg and cheese had 2 tiny pieces of the cheapest bacon they could find that weren’t even crispy. I didn’t even taste the cheese. Cheap ingredients for expensive prices. B...

$$ $$

4.00 (332 reviews) (~0.74 km from centre)

Bagel Deli Gourmet

Bagel shop

$ $$$

4.40 (298 reviews) (~5.86 km from centre)

Strathmore Bagels

Bagel shop

👍👍 If you are in the Stonybrook/Lake Grove area and you haven’t been here - you absolutely should try it out! I come here often and today I was craving a classic Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich and as always - Nailed it 👏🏻 AMAZING STAFF - they are the nicest people ever, even under stressful situations...

$ $$$

4.00 (256 reviews) (~6.89 km from centre)

Jejojo Bagels Inc

Bagel shop

👍👍 We have all had 6 foot party hero's, but Jejojo makes it on bagel bread. OH MY GOSH, what a difference the bread makes. Definitely recommend them and they are reasonably priced too. I also love their breakfast sandwiches and there staff is really friendly!

$ $$$

4.10 (222 reviews) (~8.75 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

3.80 (212 reviews) (~6.02 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

3.80 (207 reviews) (~1.87 km from centre)

Bagelicious Cafe

Bagel shop

👍 ⚡ Lisa - They we're so nice & efficient. Making sure the online order was exactly right! Fast friendly service. And they decorated the cafe festive for the holidays. So nice. - Lisa Lichelle ✨

$ $$$

3.70 (205 reviews) (~6.37 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

4.00 (202 reviews) (~8.07 km from centre)

Strathmore Bagels

Bagel shop

😠 Lighty toasted, with butter should not look burnt with a gallon of butter leaking thru the wrap, soaking the brown bag and staining the seat of my car. 2nd day in a row I went to this bagel shop and recieved a burnt un edible bagel. Used to come here on a daily when I lived here but the quality just...

$ $$$

3.60 (194 reviews) (~9.55 km from centre)

Bean's Bagels & Gourmet Catering

Bagel shop

👍👍 I've been searching for my new bagel spot and so far, Beans is a winner! Each time I've gone the bagels are fresh and delicious. They have unique bagel flavors, like churro and fruity pebbles, and even crazier cream cheese flavors! The owner and staff are friendly, efficient, and care about the cust...

$$ $$

4.60 (179 reviews) (~6.91 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

3.80 (162 reviews) (~8.92 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

4.00 (162 reviews) (~8.85 km from centre)

Better On A Bagel Deli

Deli

$ $$$

4.00 (158 reviews) (~5.7 km from centre)

Dunkin'

Coffee shop

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

$ $$$

3.50 (154 reviews) (~6.02 km from centre)

Poppy Seeds Bagels

Bagel shop

👍👍 My go to place for Bagels every weekend. The everything bagel is my personal favourite also like the poppy seeds and garlic Bagel. This place has great bagels and sandwiches. The best and fresh bagels around the block. Undoubtedly best breakfast sandwich and bagels in town. Really fast service.

$ $$$

4.30 (146 reviews) (~9.01 km from centre)

Strathmore Bagel Of Mount Sinai

Bagel shop

$ $$$

4.20 (121 reviews) (~7.41 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Most reviewed Bagel shops in Setauket, United States