Best places: Jewelry buyers in Setauket, United States

👍👍 I had a great experience. The person (possibly owner) who helped me was very fast and gave me 95% of the market price for my gold. It was over 20% better price then other stores were offering me. I very highly recommend All Island Jewelry & Loan to anyone looking to sell their jewelry and gold. Very...

👍👍 Highly recommended! When my father died I had a variety of odds and ends— coins and jewelry and watches. John is extremely knowledgeable and transparent in his transactions- He explained why items had value or not and how any calculation was made. He is both friendly and fair.

👍👍 Igor is an amazing jeweler. He is very informative and wants to make sure you don’t overpay for jewelry. I brought a 2 pendant, a custom ring, and earrings all for under a price I paid for a ring elsewhere with higher cut diamonds. Loving my new jewelry and my new favorite place.

👍👍 Words can not adequately say how wonderful Barbara is! She is so knowledgeable and kind and made appraising over 200 pieces of jewelry an absolute pleasure! She even came in on her day off to expedite the appraisals for me. I HIGHLY recommend and will only ever come to Barbara from now on! She is TH...