Top rated Italian restaurants in Sheridan, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

By the Bucket - Spaghetti and Meatballs image

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Super friendly and quick! I’ve been craving some good spaghetti lately and found this gem close by! Simple and delicious!! Also the toffee butter bundt cake is sooo good!

$ $$$

5.00 (85 reviews) (~7.1 km from centre)

Carmine Lonardo's Italian

Deli

Italian deli for sausage, meatballs & sandwiches, plus pizza, pasta & catering platters.

$$ $$

4.90 (1K reviews) (~6.72 km from centre)

Oblio's

Pizza restaurant

Family-friendly spot serving creative pies with familiar toppings & homestyle Italian dishes.

$$ $$

4.80 (1.1K reviews) (~14.67 km from centre)

Pomodoro Pizza Pasta LLC

Italian restaurant

👍👍 We stumbled upon this small restaurant and were so afoot we did. Absolutely delicious food at reasonable prices and portions were generous. We had the special Palisade grilled peaches burrata & prosciutto salad, penne puttanesca & fusilli alla Barese(?). Everything was so good, like what I had in It...

$$ $$

4.80 (377 reviews) (~15.5 km from centre)

Bettola Bistro

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Hidden gem in an Aurora strip mall! Waitstaff was excellent. Food and drinks were exquisite.

$$ $$

4.80 (335 reviews) (~13.75 km from centre)

HipPOPs handcrafted gelato bars

Ice cream shop

👍👍 Absolutely Fantastic!! I couldn’t be more impressed with HipPOPS. We hired them for an event because they came highly recommended. They well exceeded our expectations with their professionalism, delicious pops and wonderful staff. They were so accommodating, friendly and left everyone wanting more!...

$ $$$

4.80 (225 reviews) (~0.76 km from centre)

Paulie's Italian Grill

Italian restaurant

👍👍 UNBELIEVABLE EXPERIENCE. I was a little intimidated at first, but we’ve heard great things from friends who have made the Paulie’s Pilgrimage so we decided to go for it. You need to call ahead knowing what you want. You can find pictures of the menu online. Don’t waste Paul’s time on the phone. He’...

4.80 (180 reviews) (~24.6 km from centre)

Abrusci's Fire & Vine

Italian restaurant

Easygoing Italian fixture for family-style pasta & meat dishes, with some gluten-free options.

$$ $$

4.70 (5.5K reviews) (~15.28 km from centre)

Grammy's Goodies

Italian restaurant

Simple, family-owned counter serve offering pan pizza, sandwiches, pasta & homestyle baked goods.

$$ $$

4.70 (2.6K reviews) (~15.14 km from centre)

Yianni's Gyros Place

Greek restaurant

Informal sandwich shop with daily specials & a regular menu of traditional Greek & Italian entrees.

$ $$$

4.70 (1.7K reviews) (~12.88 km from centre)

Tavernetta

Italian restaurant

Upscale, buzzy Italian hot spot from an acclaimed team with an open kitchen and a fireplace lounge.

$$$ $

4.70 (1.7K reviews) (~11.96 km from centre)

Postino LoHi

Restaurant

Italian spot serving a wide selection of bruschetta & wine in rustic-chic digs with outdoor seating.

$$ $$

4.70 (1.6K reviews) (~12.79 km from centre)

Postino Broadway

Restaurant

👍👍 This place is always great. The service has consistently been good and the food is all delicious. They have an awesome happy hour but any time of the day is worth a stop. I've enjoyed it for lunch a few times and have done the range of soup and paninis to the bruschettas and charcuterie to salads. E...

$$ $$

4.70 (968 reviews) (~8.64 km from centre)