Best places: Ice cream shops in Shirley, United States

Colorful retro scoop shop dispensing ice cream & soft-serve in classic & creative flavors.

Landmark dessert spot dishing up housemade ice cream in traditional & custom flavors, plus cakes.

👍👍 These cookies are absolutely delicious. Love the fact that they make the desserts in front of you as well, pretty interactive

Cones, ice cream cakes & other frozen treats are served at this homey neighborhood fixture.

👍👍 Me and my daughter came all the way from Queens for Aloha! What a great find. Super clean premises and friendly staffs. Everything we ordered were freshly made. The ingredients and sauces are really well balanced & healthy. We will definitely come back again.

👍👍 First time here and I loved it!!!!! Nice variety of donuts to pick from. I picked a peach cobbler and sand dollar. The cashier , the young gentleman who took my order was NOT lying when he said the donuts are fresh. It was so soft I couldn't believe it. The birthday cake milkshake was definitely del...

👍👍 The ice cream at this place and atmosphere is OUT OF THIS WORLD (pun intended). This was my first time trying this place and I loved it. The staff there last night were so super nice (such a plus to be welcomed and treated with kindness) they explained the menu and our options for ice cream, they ma...

👍👍 Incredible homemade ice cream that will satisfy your sweet tooth. New flavors often and the owner is awesome! Way better than Ralph's. New Caramel banana ice cream is delicious and rainbow cookie underneath is the way to go😀

👍👍 The best coffee and Gelato you'll ever have. Great service. Quaint little place

👍👍 Very tasty ice cream and I can see why it's the best of Long Island. I got the mint chocolate chip and it was awesome.

Staten Island-born chain dispensing Italian ices & ice cream in 100-plus flavors since 1928.

👍👍 My family and I moved out here to mastic beach about a month ago and at first I was a little nervous about the area. I keep finding these great areas and from the great reviews my family went last night and I had the banana split and my wife and daughter had the sundae and besides the excellent ser...

👍👍 Nice place. Super tasty. The stuff is attentive . Heaven of ice cream

Staten Island-born chain dispensing Italian ices & ice cream in 100-plus flavors since 1928.

😠 This used to be my favorite ice cream shop. They loved when I came in twice a week spending $30 At a time. I just got here at 945. Looking to buy a quart and they refused to let me in. Big boss man just sat in the back while his employees were acting rude. Im telling you no one spends more a week th...

👍👍 Not your typical ice cream shop! Enjoy McNulty’s delicious ice cream presented in a fun and creative way. Something for everyone, including frozen yogurt and dairy free ice cream. Staff is welcoming and helpful. This shop is a must try!!!!!

Staten Island-born chain dispensing Italian ices & ice cream in 100-plus flavors since 1928.