Hidden gems: places in Sleepy Hollow

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Sleepy Hollow. Ratings are based from 24 places in the city.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Fred Astaire Dance Studios - Tarrytown image
1
Fred Astaire Dance Studios - Tarrytown
Dance school
5.00 (97 reviews)
El Troncaleño image
3
El Troncaleño
Restaurant
5.00 (5 reviews)
NorthLight image
4
NorthLight
Apartment rental agency
🫤 I don't reside here, but as a mobile professional and avid guest (my parents live here), I have repeatedly had awkward experiences with management. Rules seem to be made up or strictly enforced, for example. I'm (always) traveling with my pet, and guests don't have access to the pet “spaw” where I w...
4.90 (62 reviews)
Greene County Deli image
5
Greene County Deli
Deli
$ $$$
4.80 (81 reviews)
Old Style Horseman bridge image
6
Old Style Horseman bridge
Hiking area
4.80 (13 reviews)
Old Dutch Burying Ground image
7
Old Dutch Burying Ground
Cemetery
4.80 (6 reviews)
Casaletto Pizzeria image
9
Casaletto Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The pizza is so good! The service and staff were great. There was a solid variety to choose from. I am 100% satisfied with every aspect of my pizza experience!
$$ $$
4.70 (74 reviews)
Douglas Park image
10
Douglas Park
Park
👍👍 Beautiful a love it fresh air peace we had a good time discovering the little houses in the trees it is lovely
4.70 (66 reviews)
Welcome to Sleepy Hollow - Welcome Sign image
11
Welcome to Sleepy Hollow - Welcome Sign
Tourist attraction
👍👍 Enjoyed my first visit to the town. We had a wonderful time.
4.70 (42 reviews)
Spring Hill Apartments image
12
Spring Hill Apartments
Apartment building
👍👍 Love living here...hate that I have to move after 8 years.....
4.70 (7 reviews)
Barnhart Park image
13
Barnhart Park
Park
👍👍 Clean park. Mostly litter free. Police presence is always nearby or around, so that helps to keep it clean and safe. Can't comment much on the children's space but it looks appropriate, safe, and clean for kids. They have a nice basketball court and three volleyball fields to play on. The table area...
4.60 (140 reviews)
Coco Taqueria image
14
Coco Taqueria
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 Great tacos! The service is fast and friendly. The parking is metered outside but doesn’t have an app so bring change. I recommend getting the tacos but I also have ordered other things. There are only a few tables but always seems to be one available. I like the food and the workers are nice.
$$ $$
4.60 (121 reviews)
J & G Italian Deli image
15
J & G Italian Deli
Deli
👍👍 Good deli sandwich. Freshly cut meat and cheese for your sandwich. The side options are good too. There are a lot of tables inside and a couple out front. It’s affordable and fast and you see locals in the line so that’s a good sign. I now have been here several times and always enjoy the warm atti...
4.60 (118 reviews)
ChuChok Thai image
16
ChuChok Thai
Thai restaurant
😐 Honestly, I was really looking forward to trying this place for the longest time as I've been on the hunt for a proper Thai place in the area. I came out a bit disappointed by the experience. Drunken noodles is my go to dish and how I gauge a thai restaurant. While the flavor was present I was quite...
4.60 (93 reviews)
Ichabod's Landing image
17
Ichabod's Landing
Townhouse complex
4.60 (40 reviews)
Kensi-Go Kitchen image
18
Kensi-Go Kitchen
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 The food is delicious and great customer service.
$$ $$
4.60 (35 reviews)
Rockefeller Estate Visitor Center image
19
Rockefeller Estate Visitor Center
Visitor center
4.60 (9 reviews)
Gustito Dominicano Restaurant image
20
Gustito Dominicano Restaurant
Dominican restaurant
👍👍 I’m Dominican and I give this establishment a 10 out of 10 on their food. Very delicious and CLEAN which is most important when eating out. Will definitely be going back whenever in town.
$$ $$
4.50 (100 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )