Top rated Italian restaurants in St. Marys, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in St. Marys

Experience the best that St. Marys has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 289 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within St. Marys

BABA'S Gyros N More

Middle Eastern restaurant

👍👍 Truly made with love. Visited the former restaurant from out of town with my mother months ago and received such warm service that we promised to come back once the new one opened. The owner Sam was so enthusiastic and generous and personally chose our menu items for us. He gave me the #4 (Shredded...

$ $$$

4.90 (382 reviews) (~29.64 km from centre)

Joes Italian Ottumwa

Italian restaurant

$$ $$

4.90 (48 reviews) (~115.38 km from centre)

Orsi's Italian Bakery & Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Long-running Italian throwback offering specialty foodstuffs, baked goods & pizza in casual digs.

$$ $$

4.80 (2K reviews) (~183.39 km from centre)

Caniglia's A Mano

Italian restaurant

👍👍 I love everything here, but their Veggie pizza is amazing. I never thought I would like a pizza without meat on it. The sausage and peppers pizza (pictured) is also one of my favorites.

$$ $$

4.80 (450 reviews) (~192.53 km from centre)

Ugo's Pizzaland

Pizza restaurant

$$ $$

4.80 (430 reviews) (~199.56 km from centre)

Nonna’s Pizza & Pasta

Italian restaurant

👍👍 We went in for dinner last night and the place was really busy. The staff were very attentive and friendly. We were able to get a nice spot at the bar and had some excellent drinks while we waited for our meals. The atmosphere is a little crazy but we enjoy watching people and talking with folks....

$$ $$

4.80 (341 reviews) (~50.02 km from centre)

Geno's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Chain outlet serving pizza, plus pasta, calzones, chicken wings & submarine sandwiches.

$$ $$

4.80 (217 reviews) (~173.42 km from centre)

Sal Vitale's Italian Restaurant Pizza & Pasta

Restaurant

4.80 (165 reviews) (~212.4 km from centre)

Napoli's Italian Restaurant SW

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Delicious food and beautiful new space! Would be perfect for a date night or family dinner. My favorite (besides the rolls, which are unbelievable) is the Tour of Italy with Fettuccine Alfredo, Lasagna, and Chicken Parmesan. The tomato soup is also outstanding!

$$ $$

4.80 (45 reviews) (~182.23 km from centre)

Mangia Italiana

Italian restaurant

Informal counter-serve spot offering standard Italian & Sicilian sandwiches, pizzas & pasta dishes.

$$ $$

4.70 (1.6K reviews) (~193.94 km from centre)

Cosi Cucina Italian Grill

Italian restaurant

Low-key eatery doling out generous servings of Italian-style pasta, pizza & entrees.

$$ $$

4.70 (1.2K reviews) (~33.63 km from centre)

Zoey's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Vintage neighborhood joint turning out both thin-crust & deep-dish pizzas plus beer & wine.

$$ $$

4.70 (1.2K reviews) (~194.59 km from centre)

Napoli Pizza & Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Get there early or make a reservation because they were packed and doing crazy take out orders. My sister recommended pizza and it was really good. The Gyros and Greek salad were spot on. We’re new in town and plan on returning.

$ $$$

4.70 (1K reviews) (~227.27 km from centre)

Sal Vitale's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 If you are looking for authentic Sicilian cuisine look no further. I have lived and worked international and having been to Sicily and Italy several times, I can say that Sal Vitale’s taste just as if you were to sit down in a restaurant in Palmero or Messina in Sicily or in Rome. Sal Vitale’s uses...

$$ $$

4.70 (890 reviews) (~225.79 km from centre)

Tiramisu

Italian restaurant

Thin-crust pizzas, pastas & traditional Italian mains served in a warm, wood-paneled trattoria.

$$ $$

4.70 (849 reviews) (~248.52 km from centre)

La Tavola Italian Eatery

Italian restaurant

Casual restaurant featuring pizzas & hearty Italian plates in a cheery, cozy setting.

$$ $$

4.70 (664 reviews) (~227.2 km from centre)

Gianna's Italian Beef

Restaurant

👍👍 Great Italian beef sandwiches, wet or dipped completely. Spicy and/or sweet peppers, and cheese optional. I only get Italian beef as it is so good. Eventually I might try some others but haven't found a reason to yet. Update: I still love this place. Glad to see they are still around.

$ $$$

4.70 (521 reviews) (~187.12 km from centre)

Mirabito's Italian

Italian restaurant

$$ $$

4.70 (508 reviews) (~183.32 km from centre)

Northern Lights Pizza (104)

Pizza restaurant

Thin-crust pizzas, pasta & flatbread sandwiches served in a no-frills setting.

4.70 (416 reviews) (~32.39 km from centre)

Lucca

Italian restaurant

Chic outpost serving modern & traditional Italian dishes, some with North African influence.

$$ $$

4.70 (376 reviews) (~32.86 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in St. Marys, United States