Top rated Sandwich shops in West Islip

Experience the best that West Islip has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 56 places from Sandwich shop category.

Sort results by

Best  
๐Ÿ”ฅ
Top rated  
๐Ÿ†
Most reviewed  
๐Ÿคฉ
Hidden gems  
๐Ÿ’Ž
Worst rated  
๐Ÿคฌ
Recently discovered  
๐Ÿ†•

Search radius



Hometown Heroes image
1
Hometown Heroes
Sandwich shop
๐Ÿ˜  Soo happy i was given a blue cheese hero today with 2 pieces of chicken. Place is going down hill.
$$ $$
4.50 (302 reviews) (~0.33 km from centre)
Grilli's Gourmet Deli & Catering image
2
Grilli's Gourmet Deli & Catering
Deli
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Family owned and run. Polite, they know nearly everyoneโ€™s name. And they try to be the cheapest in the area. Fresh salads, displays always look nice.
$ $$$
4.50 (142 reviews) (~9.21 km from centre)
Deli Zone Gourmet Pizza & Catering image
3
Deli Zone Gourmet Pizza & Catering
Pizza restaurant
๐Ÿ˜  Today 7/21/22 I ordered a combo soup and hero from this Deli. While I was drinking my soup I put in my mouth a piece of a faucet pipe. I can assumed the metal being inside the soup was an unfortunate accident while prepping or not sure how that piece of metal was inside the pot. However this is tot...
$$ $$
4.50 (58 reviews) (~8.92 km from centre)
Pigs on a Wing image
4
Pigs on a Wing
Barbecue restaurant
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ My daughter and I stopped in for lunch. We had boneless wings (sweet chili and honey bbq) and chili cheese fries. We definitely underestimated how filling it was and I could only eat three of the giant wings. They were all white meat, tender and juicy on the inside and sauce was yummy. The people wh...
$$ $$
4.40 (239 reviews) (~6.04 km from centre)
35th Street Family Deli Inc image
5
35th Street Family Deli Inc
Deli
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Love the family atmosphere & the great attitude of the staff. A place with good food & a variety of options.
4.40 (58 reviews) (~6.94 km from centre)
Copiague Bagel & Deli image
6
Copiague Bagel & Deli
Bagel shop
๐Ÿซค This used to be the spot to go but unfortunately the prices are higher then the norm. BEC on a roll or bagel is $7 & comes with NOTHING. It wouldnโ€™t be so bad if the sandwich was thick but it lacks luster. Go down the block to Schwartz or Lindy Bagels right on Montauk Hywy. Prices are cheaper & come...
$ $$$
4.30 (189 reviews) (~8.08 km from centre)
Nanitos Deli image
7
Nanitos Deli
Deli
๐Ÿ˜  I would avoid this deli, I got very sick after eating here. The food was cold and oily, and unfortunately actually made me sick. It is also quite dirty - would not be surprised to see a critter running around if you look hard enough. Pass on this deli, there are plenty of others around.
$ $$$
4.30 (165 reviews) (~4.85 km from centre)
Lindy's South Shore Bagels &Heros image
8
Lindy's South Shore Bagels &Heros
Bagel shop
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Love their bagel, come all the way from Hershey, PA to get this bagels. Real New York bagel shop, recommend to all bagel lover. They have a lots of option to choose.
4.30 (76 reviews) (~6.28 km from centre)
Arby's image
9
Arby's
Fast food restaurant
Fast-food chain, known for its roast beef, serving up hot & cold sandwiches, fries & shakes.
$ $$$
4.20 (1.2K reviews) (~6.87 km from centre)
Mulberry Street Babylon image
10
Mulberry Street Babylon
Italian restaurant
Pizzeria/restaurant serves Italian fare in sharp digs sporting brick, wood trim & elegant fixtures.
$$ $$
4.20 (465 reviews) (~1.62 km from centre)
Tropical Smoothie Cafe image
11
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Juice shop
Health-conscious cafe chain featuring a menu of custom smoothies, sandwiches & wraps.
$ $$$
4.20 (249 reviews) (~7.03 km from centre)
Boulevard Deli image
12
Boulevard Deli
Deli
๐Ÿ˜  I had just driven 17 hours from Atlanta. I was at my destination " but wanted a bite to eat" before going in to shower" and ocourse get some sleep. At this point it was around 5 am, so I google the nearest breakfast place open or near to opening. I came across boulevard deli" which from the first i...
$ $$$
4.20 (156 reviews) (~9.89 km from centre)
Kurt's Deli image
13
Kurt's Deli
Deli
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ Our favorite deli in lindenhurst. Super nice guys and great food. Everything weโ€™ve had has been awesome ๐Ÿค™
$ $$$
4.20 (124 reviews) (~6.04 km from centre)
Subway image
14
Subway
Sandwich shop
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
$ $$$
4.20 (86 reviews) (~6.45 km from centre)
Bagel & Bakery image
15
Bagel & Bakery
Bagel shop
๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘ I just left this deli 10 mins ago and my sandwich is PERFECT. Thank you Sam! He told me to tel him how I want it and heโ€™ll make it. Couldnโ€™t ask for better.
$ $$$
4.20 (61 reviews) (~6.04 km from centre)
Hero Factory Deli & Catering image
16
Hero Factory Deli & Catering
Deli
4.20 (56 reviews) (~5.93 km from centre)
Subway image
17
Subway
Sandwich shop
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
$ $$$
4.20 (36 reviews) (~8.16 km from centre)
Panera Bread image
18
Panera Bread
Cafe
Counter-serve bakery/cafe chain serving sandwiches, salads & more, known for its bread & free WiFi.
$$ $$
4.10 (761 reviews) (~6.23 km from centre)
Panera Bread image
19
Panera Bread
Cafe
Counter-serve bakery/cafe chain serving sandwiches, salads & more, known for its bread & free WiFi.
$$ $$
4.10 (567 reviews) (~6.34 km from centre)
Panera Bread image
20
Panera Bread
Cafe
Counter-serve bakery/cafe chain serving sandwiches, salads & more, known for its bread & free WiFi.
$$ $$
4.10 (447 reviews) (~4.35 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )