Top rated Italian restaurants in West Orange, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in West Orange

Experience the best that West Orange has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 162 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within West Orange

Pasta flavio

Italian restaurant

$$ $$

5.00 (58 reviews) (~6.23 km from centre)

Bivio Pizza Napoletana

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Over the past 15 years, of all the pizza places I have been to in NJ and NYC, this is by far the best. This is precision pizza making from every aspect. Not only is the pizza great, but Tomaso (the owner) is so personable and always has a smile on his face. Try to make a reservation 1 week ahead as...

4.80 (182 reviews) (~3.01 km from centre)

Vinnie's Mootz

Italian restaurant

👍👍 First time here. Order Lucky Lady sandwich, it was amazing. Bread fresh and soft, chicken crispy and soft at the same time. Mozzarella perfect. Very good combo, would definitely return for this sandwich and will try something else!

$$ $$

4.80 (167 reviews) (~9.7 km from centre)

BOSCHETTO

Italian restaurant

👍👍 I have been waiting for this place to open and it did not disappoint! It was so good, I went back two days in a row. Can’t wait to go back again. Side note, having a parking lot attached is absolutely amazing. BYO with a liquor store a few doors down. Looking forward to sitting on their patio making...

$$ $$

4.80 (136 reviews) (~3.18 km from centre)

Leo's Italian Ice & Ice Cream

Ice cream shop

👍👍 Everything about this place makes me glad this gem is so close to home. I would venture to say it's the best ice cream in NJ, not just in town. The girls attending are always nice, too. The flavors my family and I love are cinnamon churro, strawberry shortcake and there ices. All are consistently th...

4.80 (124 reviews) (~8.54 km from centre)

Bonvini's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

$$ $$

4.80 (47 reviews) (~6.32 km from centre)

ARTIE'S

Pizza restaurant

Destination featuring a bread bakery, plus a wood-fired pizzeria, wine & cocktails.

$$ $$

4.70 (1.1K reviews) (~9 km from centre)

Matthew's

Italian restaurant

Familiar Italian fare & a lengthy wine list served in a modern, minimalist setting with a full bar.

$$ $$

4.70 (1K reviews) (~7.91 km from centre)

Casa Giuseppe

Italian restaurant

👍👍 The food here is absolutely ridiculous and delicious. It was an experience I'll come back again for whenever someone asks me for Italian food. Edit: I brought my family here with a total of 5 adults and 4 kids because I love this place so much. Everyone absolutely loved the food and this place wa...

$$ $$

4.70 (389 reviews) (~10 km from centre)

Me & Tommy's Restaurant & Bar

Italian restaurant

😐 Actually I would say 3.5 stars. The food is good, even better if you like vodka sauce, which my friends tell me is excellent. The service is good and the servers are friendly. You should know that if your group is 7 people or more you will receive a limited menu, with no salad option and half the me...

$$ $$

4.70 (361 reviews) (~7.63 km from centre)

Boccone South

Italian restaurant

Pastas, soup & meat & fish dishes round out the menu at this smart Italian restaurant.

$$ $$

4.70 (323 reviews) (~9 km from centre)

Tony D's

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 The D in Tony D stands for delicious, we just moved back to the area and needed to find a gluten free pizza place as my oldest has a wheat and peanut allergy. Another reviewer called out that their gluten free was the best. I confidently agree, we've had gluten free pizza all over NJ it's hit and mi...

$ $$$

4.70 (255 reviews) (~5.78 km from centre)

Bucco Restaurant Bloomfield

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Great service and great food! Mike is great! He’s very knowledgeable about the menu and will help you make the right selection. The restaurant is cozy but is able to accommodate larger parties just by moving the tables around. They also have live music. I’ll definitely be back!

4.70 (245 reviews) (~3.45 km from centre)

Nicholas Anthony's Family Kitchen

Italian restaurant

👍👍 I’m going to need the bar top to expand. I love sitting there! My 3 plates of food take up a lot of space.Start with the shrimp beeps. The sauce here is so good. It’s really hard to choose what to eat. The staff is very attentive You really feel like your visiting your relatives for dinner.

4.70 (176 reviews) (~0.76 km from centre)

La Famiglia Ristorante, Pizzeria & Catering Maplewood

Italian restaurant

😠 Avoid, not tasty, cold, late, restaurant staff is not helpful, drivers are very aggressive(Restaurant was 10 mins away). Driver got lost multiple times. Food was almost slapped into my hand, the sauce and napkin bag was thrown at me. Yummy yummy who doesn't love a messy, and somehow dry as well as o...

$$ $$

4.70 (165 reviews) (~7.49 km from centre)

Luigino's Parmigiana

Restaurant

👍👍 I just left this place and rushed to leave a review. The food was 10/10, the portions 10/10 but the service is what really got me…INCREDIBLE!!! I wish I remembered our waiters name. He had longer hair in braids, absolutely amazing. Thank you so much for being so polite and for the birthday treat. W...

$$ $$

4.70 (151 reviews) (~2.63 km from centre)

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 We just stopped in here after attending a funeral. We're from Philly. Not realizing that this location is take out, the staff cleaned off a table, complete with adding a centerpiece of mums, and proceeded to make us feel so welcome. The food was delicious. We had sandwiches, fries and a slice of...

$$ $$

4.70 (144 reviews) (~9.05 km from centre)

Guys Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

😐 Their pizza is actually not bad. It’s a very small place with no area really to wait for pickup. I would not recommend taking younger children to dine in there since the staff spent the entire time screaming profanities at each other.

$ $$$

4.70 (68 reviews) (~2.53 km from centre)

Muriale's Trattoria & Italian Delicacies

Deli

👍👍 I've been here several times recently each time I've tried something different. The food is consistently excellent and fresh,and the portions are ample. I will be back.

4.70 (63 reviews) (~9.69 km from centre)

Sofia’s Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

$$ $$

4.70 (49 reviews) (~1.69 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in West Orange, United States