Top rated Coin dealers in Brookfield, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Coin dealers in Brookfield

Experience the best that Brookfield has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 17 places from Coin dealer category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Brookfield

Hertels Gold & Coin Shop

Coin dealer

🫤 Friendly family staff. But what the owner offered me for my two US Mint OGP complete items was atrocious. I was able to sell them on eBay. Even after eBay fees I was able to make $70 more than the first item, and another $70 more than the second item. The first item he offered me $40 less what the M...

4.90 (73 reviews) (~97.24 km from centre)

International Gold & Silver Buyers

Jewelry buyer

😠 The guy was a completely rude and unprofessional as soon as I walked in I was greeted with “what’d you want” I asked him if he buys used jewelry (because that’s what it says on the sign) which he replied it depends what do you have and before he even looked at what I said he said nope don’t want it...

4.80 (303 reviews) (~11.39 km from centre)

Costa's Coins & Currency

Coin dealer

4.80 (94 reviews) (~86.95 km from centre)

Trader Jon's

Pawn shop

👍👍 This place is a real treasure. You go in wanting one item and come out with numerous treasures. 10/10 nostalgia factor. Jon is a true blue collar hard working guy who welcomes you in from start to finish. Great prices which are more than negotiable so you leave feeling you got a good deal. Wide...

4.70 (141 reviews) (~75.87 km from centre)

Spotlight Coins Appointment only M-F 8-4

Coin dealer

4.70 (31 reviews) (~68.19 km from centre)

Silver Spring Coin & Jewelry

Coin dealer

👍👍 Wow, the list of positive things I could say about this shop... Keith is an honest, upstanding dealer with the highest level of integrity. I dropped a small gold coin and couldn't find it when I got home. Searched the car, my garage, everywhere... thought I lost it forever. Got a call from the shop...

4.60 (42 reviews) (~28.73 km from centre)

Greater Milwaukee Coin

Coin dealer

😐 The original owners, Russ and Ken, were staples in the local coin community; however, there are new owners now. When the store was reopening, I brought in a few coins and a small amount of gold in to sell. A few of my items were not really looked at, but they passed on the coins that they did take...

4.50 (172 reviews) (~3.72 km from centre)

Shorewood Coin Shop

Coin dealer

4.50 (54 reviews) (~19.84 km from centre)

The Coin Shop

Coin dealer

4.40 (106 reviews) (~84.66 km from centre)

The Goldsmith

Jewelry store

😠 My father has cancer, stage 4, and brought in two rings. He took the diamonds from one and turned it into a cross necklace for my mother. The second ring went missing and we went back to the store, they were very nice and told my father nor to worry they'd work with him with what he wanted. My...

4.40 (45 reviews) (~83.73 km from centre)

J & G's Coins, Rings and Things

Coin dealer

👍👍 I would just like to say that if you want something really nice and at great prices then this is the place to go . They are very honest and great people to work with !!! I have bought a few things and I am very satisfied !! I know that if I wasnt satisfied that they would make it good! I would re...

4.40 (37 reviews) (~96.68 km from centre)

L & B Coins & Collectibles

Coin dealer

😐 I'd easily give them five stars if I hadn't gone by there three times recently when they're suppose to be open and they're not! If a business lists their business hours online and at their own store but aren't open the hours they state, I will not waste my time.

4.40 (32 reviews) (~97.21 km from centre)

Harbor Coin

Coin dealer

👍👍 We found a couple of coins in a house that we bought. Never having experienced buying or selling gold or silver in my life we went with the nearest shop closest to us. We got an estimate on our small bundle and decided to get a second opinion. That second opinion gave us quite a bit less than Harb...

4.30 (53 reviews) (~77.3 km from centre)

Old World Coin

Coin dealer

4.20 (129 reviews) (~80.05 km from centre)

Oak Creek Currency & Coin

Coin dealer

😠 This guy only offered me $8 a gram for my gold when the spot price was $41.98 a gram. Then when I ask why so low he told me to sell it to the internet. I went to derzon coin they pay spot price.

4.10 (55 reviews) (~27.38 km from centre)

David Derzon Coins

Coin dealer

😠 I stopped in there today to get a quote and possibly sell eight US gold coins. I had gone there two months prior to sell bullion and to see if they would treat me fair. The numismatist was not there when I arrived and was helped at the counter by an associate. All coins were pre 1933. All he did wa...

3.90 (35 reviews) (~8.58 km from centre)

American Coin & Jewelry

Coin dealer

🫤 From what I’ve experienced, if you’re there to buy, market is hot. If you’re there to sell, market is soft. I believe my 87 year old father got taken for a ride. He purchased 3 rare pennies for over 2100.00 from them over the past couple years. He just sold his entire collection ( that included the...

3.30 (58 reviews) (~44.55 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Coin dealers in Brookfield, United States