Top rated Italian restaurants in Monticello, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Monticello

Experience the best that Monticello has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 734 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Monticello

Luciani's Pizza

Pizza Takeout

👍👍 the bechamel pizza is delicious, the combination of sauce with cheese, toppings and truffle oil is an explosion of flavors in your mouth, 100/10. we will definitely return many times. can't wait to try the whole menu

$$ $$

5.00 (81 reviews) (~97.68 km from centre)

T & V’S Authentic Italian LLC

Pizza restaurant

$ $$$

5.00 (37 reviews) (~207.57 km from centre)

Varasano's Pizzeria - Buckhead

Pizza restaurant

Buzzy, relaxed eatery featuring traditional sourdough thin-crust pizza, plus pasta & small plates.

$ $$$

4.90 (2.3K reviews) (~86.65 km from centre)

Yeppa & Co.

Italian restaurant

😐 Heard alot about this new Italian restaurant. Finally got to try it on a weekend for dinner. We were seated immediately without any reservation. They did not have enough vegetarian options, but we did manage to order some sides like brocollini, roasted mushrooms, zucchini and onions, polenta fries w...

4.90 (2.1K reviews) (~87.51 km from centre)

Hoboken Cafe on Whitlock

Italian restaurant

👍👍 The real deal, couldn't believe I've missed out on this place. I had the meatball hero. It saved my day! The bread is delightful, the sauce isn't overcooked and bitter like most places. Very robust and simple at the same time. JUST TRY IT already! Planning my next visit soon!

$$ $$

4.90 (1K reviews) (~109.35 km from centre)

Italy's Pizza & Pasta Company

Italian restaurant

👍👍 This place was REALLY GREAT! The food was good, the people was really friendly and the atmosphere was nice! It is one of those nice finds that you would come back to again and again. We were there for lunch during the week and had a nice relaxing time before finishing our shopping expedition. We ord...

4.90 (170 reviews) (~102.17 km from centre)

Honeycream

Ice cream shop

4.90 (146 reviews) (~173.37 km from centre)

Vendetti’s Pizza Pasta Grill Gainesville

Restaurant

4.90 (48 reviews) (~110.39 km from centre)

Nina’s Pizza Kitchen

Italian restaurant

👍👍 We did carry out and everything was delicious!! Staff was very helpful and considerate. We definitely will be back!

$$ $$

4.90 (37 reviews) (~119.97 km from centre)

Luciano's Ristorante Italiano

Italian restaurant

Italian favorites & a deep wine list offered in a relaxed, modern space with a fireplace & a patio.

$$ $$

4.80 (4.4K reviews) (~85.67 km from centre)

Forza Storico

Italian restaurant

Roman-inspired pastas & mains dished out in a cool outpost with a bar & expansive outdoor seating.

4.80 (2K reviews) (~86.18 km from centre)

a mano

Italian restaurant

Handmade pasta & other seasonal Italian dishes, in a cozy cottage with a snug bar & patio.

$$ $$

4.80 (1.1K reviews) (~81.41 km from centre)

Atalian

Italian restaurant

👍👍 The hubs and I are definitely coming back. We went for an early dinner on Sunday, and the service was impeccable. Everything from the appetizers to the entrees were delicious! We had the chimichurri steak, lasagna, lamb and shrimp scampi. All of the dishes were so rich and flavorful, but not overpo...

4.80 (752 reviews) (~82.45 km from centre)

Ferraro's Kitchen Blue Ridge

Italian restaurant

4.80 (479 reviews) (~183.32 km from centre)

Belladina's Pizzeria of Greenville

Pizza restaurant

Unfussy option whipping up Italian staples such as pasta & pizza, plus stromboli & sandwiches.

$$ $$

4.80 (476 reviews) (~208.71 km from centre)

Home Fresh Bistro

Bistro

👍👍 Nice surprise downtown and worth taking the business route. Nice menu with a variety of items and specials. Free cake on Tuesday’s. Server was kind, quick and efficient. Food was presented well and served quickly. Bun on pulled pork sandwich could have been more fresh but beans and potato salad were...

$$ $$

4.80 (425 reviews) (~123.31 km from centre)

Mariolino's Italian Cuisine

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Everything was Excellent! It really was. We were heading home after 3 days in the Smokies, it was lunchtime and we saw a sign for Mariolino's. The restaurant was totally clean with a wonderful Italian atmosphere, service was so fast it was almost scary, and our food was beautiful and delicious. The...

$$ $$

4.80 (392 reviews) (~211.29 km from centre)

Brothers Italian Cuisine

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Best NY style pizza 🍕 around, my wife is from NY and she approves 👍. I got the spaghetti 🍝and it was great! My wife got the chicken parm sub and fries 🍟. She said it was the best she'd had in a long time.

4.80 (215 reviews) (~162.52 km from centre)

Gigi's Italian Kitchen & Restaurant

Italian restaurant

👍👍 One of best meals I’ve ever had. In season produce, fresh fish/proteins all well sourced and handled with love and finesse. Can’t stop thinking about the meal we had. Life’s good when you eat good

4.80 (154 reviews) (~79.01 km from centre)

Mangia on Main

Italian restaurant

$ $$$

4.80 (122 reviews) (~51.95 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Monticello, United States