Best places: Pie shops in New Carlisle

Discover the best places in New Carlisle, curated using our unique algorithm blending 'Top Rated' and 'Most Reviewed' establishments. Uncover the city's gems and must-visit locales for an unforgettable experience. This list contains 60 places from Pie shop category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Pleasant House Pub image
1
Pleasant House Pub
Pub
Rustic cafe with a blackboard menu of farm-to-table fare, baked goods, brunch & Sunday tea service.
$$ $$
4.70 (1.3K reviews) (~95.81 km from centre)
Spinning J Bakery and Soda Fountain image
2
Spinning J Bakery and Soda Fountain
Cafe
Seasonal pies, gelato and soda-fountain classics served in quaint surrounds with vintage furniture.
$$ $$
4.70 (945 reviews) (~100.9 km from centre)
First Slice Pie Cafe image
3
First Slice Pie Cafe
Pie shop
Simple cafe specializing in fruit & cream-filled pies, along with quiche, sandwiches & salads.
$ $$$
4.70 (784 reviews) (~100.99 km from centre)
Konrad's Bakery image
4
Konrad's Bakery
Bakery
👍👍 Wow! This place is definitely worthy of 5 stars. It is conveniently located with ample parking and the exterior is impeccably clean. The inside is immaculate with nicely displayed cases and a inviting seating area. The staff was very sweet and patient while I looked at all it’s offerings. I ch...
$$ $$
4.80 (361 reviews) (~164.7 km from centre)
Schmucker's Restaurant image
5
Schmucker's Restaurant
Diner
Homey diner with yellow brick walls, serving classic comfort food & over 20 kinds of pie.
$ $$$
4.60 (3.4K reviews) (~236 km from centre)
The Elegant Farmer image
6
The Elegant Farmer
Grocery store
4.60 (2.5K reviews) (~197.22 km from centre)
Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits image
7
Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits
Pie shop
Rustic bakery with a rotating menu of homemade sweet & savory pies & biscuits for eat-in or takeout.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.5K reviews) (~101.39 km from centre)
Myrtle's Pie image
8
Myrtle's Pie
Pie shop
$$ $$
4.80 (309 reviews) (~248.46 km from centre)
Rise’n Roll Bakery-Schererville image
9
Rise’n Roll Bakery-Schererville
Bakery
👍👍 Absolutely amazing! I have never had such moist donuts. There is so much to choose from, and it all looks so good, and smells even better. Great service and very fair pricing as well. I will definitely plan on being back when I’m in town.
$$ $$
4.70 (503 reviews) (~83.26 km from centre)
The Coffee Pot image
10
The Coffee Pot
Coffee shop
👍👍 I really enjoyed The Coffee Pot. It's a beautuful coffee shop and a steady line of customers who were waited on quickly. My chicken noodle soup warmed me up quickly and was so good! My husband got a HUGE serving of chocolate cake that that was...oh-my-goodness delish!! We will be back! Soon.
$$ $$
4.70 (469 reviews) (~237.89 km from centre)
Hoosier Mama Pie Company image
11
Hoosier Mama Pie Company
Pie shop
A rotating menu of homemade sweet & savory pies on offer in a cute shop with a retro look.
$$ $$
4.60 (682 reviews) (~98.48 km from centre)
Rise’n Roll Bakery — Fishers image
12
Rise’n Roll Bakery — Fishers
Donut shop
👍👍 I live in Florida but whenever I’m in town to visit family, I stop in. The Cinnamon Caramel donut is one of the most divine donuts I’ve ever had. It just melts in your mouth. I’m sure that everything is amazing but I’m so addicted to these. Already looking forward to my next return.
4.70 (321 reviews) (~198.65 km from centre)
Baker's Nook Cafe image
13
Baker's Nook Cafe
Restaurant
👍👍 This place is a gem! Tucked away in a strip mall near downtown and the river is this treat. It is a family-run bakery/coffee shop that serves excellent food. I've had 2 breakfasts here, and both have been very good. The coffee is top-notch! The food is real, homemade and tasty! They have tons of f...
$ $$$
4.70 (319 reviews) (~45.06 km from centre)
Honeypie Cafe image
14
Honeypie Cafe
Diner
Retro-style eatery with patio serving creative comfort food & desserts made from local ingredients.
$$ $$
4.50 (2K reviews) (~184.08 km from centre)
Rise'n Roll Bakery image
15
Rise'n Roll Bakery
Bakery
👍👍 This place is under new ownership and in my opinion is run wonderfully. The staff is very kind and helpful, catering to your every question and need. I tried a breakfast muffin and a chocolate donut. Both were splendid. The breakfast muffin was on a soft, buttery biscuit and had a lot of flavor and...
$ $$$
4.80 (216 reviews) (~215.89 km from centre)
SmallPie image
16
SmallPie
Cafe
🫤 I ordered the blueberry rhubarb pie and this is what I got. Don’t get me wrong, their pies (cream or fruit) are delicious but for $7.50 a slice, they should be more generous slices of pie. It’s always hit or miss with the sizing of the slices. Sometimes you’ll get a nice large piece, the next time i...
$$ $$
4.60 (478 reviews) (~182.1 km from centre)
Nick's Kitchen image
17
Nick's Kitchen
American restaurant
$ $$$
4.50 (1.1K reviews) (~124.24 km from centre)
Bud's Restaurant image
18
Bud's Restaurant
American restaurant
Old-fashioned diner-style restaurant serving classic American fare & pies since 1939.
$ $$$
4.60 (445 reviews) (~184.74 km from centre)
Dollop Coffee & The Hoosier Mama Pie Company image
19
Dollop Coffee & The Hoosier Mama Pie Company
Pie shop
Chill outpost serving specialty coffees & teas, plus housemade eats & locally sourced baked goods.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.1K reviews) (~103.6 km from centre)
Titus Bakery image
20
Titus Bakery
Bakery
Popular, long-running bakery supplying classic & creative donuts, plus sandwiches & local coffee.
$ $$$
4.60 (412 reviews) (~183.88 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near New Carlisle

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )