Best Sports card stores in New Carlisle, United States to visit (UPDATED April, 2024)

Best places: Sports card stores in New Carlisle

Discover the best places in New Carlisle, curated using our unique algorithm blending 'Top Rated' and 'Most Reviewed' establishments. Uncover the city's gems and must-visit locales for an unforgettable experience. This list contains 20 places from Sports card store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New Carlisle

Premier Gold, Silver, & Coin

Collectibles store

👍 This was a interesting experience! My suggestion is they should have 2 or more buyers working. I got there a 10am opening time, maybe 6 people in front of me. I finally got called back about 2:45pm , left at almost 4pm. Times very on the items people bring but this was a crazy wait time. Many left t...

4.90 (1.9K reviews) (~220.79 km from centre)

Card Pop USA

Sports card store

5.00 (424 reviews) (~134.43 km from centre)

Price's Collectibles

Sports card store

4.90 (255 reviews) (~184.34 km from centre)

Primetime Sportscards & Collectibles

Trading card store

4.90 (237 reviews) (~139.69 km from centre)

TCB Games Inc

Game store

4.60 (400 reviews) (~124.15 km from centre)

Kryptonite Kollectibles

Game store

😠 Years ago I would order products for when they came out, they would never arrive on time. Someone at the store even told me a product hadn't come out yet that was supposed to release on my birthday I saw it at other stores, and it had released on time. I was told by the staff repeatedly it was pushe...

4.60 (397 reviews) (~234.67 km from centre)

Johnson Creek Card Shop and Collectibles

Sports card store

4.90 (143 reviews) (~240.71 km from centre)

Legends Sports & Games

Sports card store

4.50 (259 reviews) (~155.3 km from centre)

More Fun Sports Cards

Sports card store

👍👍 Ken has an amazing shop! Fair prices, great customer service, very knowledgeable. Alot of cards to choose from and other great memorabilia!! Great place to shop as a kid or adult.

4.80 (95 reviews) (~86.41 km from centre)

OC Sports Cards & Memorabilia

Sports card store

5.00 (52 reviews) (~240.55 km from centre)

Corn Coast

Comic book store

4.80 (64 reviews) (~124.39 km from centre)

Bricks & Ivy Sports

Sports card store

4.80 (48 reviews) (~168.09 km from centre)

Seven Out Cards & Collectibles

Collectibles store

4.90 (42 reviews) (~185.17 km from centre)

Mitch's Sports Cards & Collectibles

Trading card store

👍👍 By far my favorite place for all things sports cards! Incredible selections and prices, and Mitch is one of the most knowledgeable and friendly guys around! Highly recommend and will continue to bring my business here! I suggest you do to!

5.00 (34 reviews) (~207.98 km from centre)

Baseball Card Exchange

Sports memorabilia store

😠 Used them for the first time recently. Only spent about $100 on several "unopened" packs. I felt that it was easily apparent that at least half the packs had been opened and resealed. I have no confidence in their "authentication process". For example, in one "unopened" 1982 Fleer Baseball card pack...

4.00 (209 reviews) (~82.5 km from centre)