Top rated Thrift stores in Newburgh, United States to elevate your visit (Updated April, 2024)

Top rated Thrift stores in Newburgh

Experience the best that Newburgh has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 96 places from Thrift store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Newburgh

Eco Evolution

Coffee shop

👍👍 Eco Evolution is a gem! Enter the SoNo storefront and you'll find incredible products that help to save the Earth, as well as walls fills with products crafted by local artisans. There's always something new on the shelves to check out. Plus it's just a great space to hang out - there's definitely...

5.00 (150 reviews) (~66.97 km from centre)

Only Rare NYC

Ice cream shop

👍👍 The rolled ice cream here is awesome. They gotta step they spoon game up though, I need a stronger spoon than them flimsy plastic ones🤷🏽‍♂️👍🏾

5.00 (115 reviews) (~94.69 km from centre)

Simple Bare Necessities

Grocery store

👍👍 I AM SO EXCITED THERE IS STORE LIKE THIS IN SUSSEX COUNTY! I love the zero waste and bring your own container approach. I can’t believe how inexpensive some of the items came out to be! They have pantry staples, spices, oils and vinegars as well as cleaning supplies and this is just the greatest sto...

5.00 (88 reviews) (~73.59 km from centre)

Second Chance Shoppe

Thrift store

5.00 (81 reviews) (~46.4 km from centre)

A.S. & Sons Diamonds Corp | Pawn Shop

Pawn shop

👍👍 Last weekend my wife and I were in the city and wondered into A.S. & Sons Jewelry Store. We were immediately greeted by a young man by the name of Michail. A clean cut fellow with a big smile. He asked us if we were looking for anything in particular. We explained we were looking for a graduation...

4.90 (250 reviews) (~99.63 km from centre)

Unearth Vintage

Vintage clothing store

Modest, independently owned vintage-clothing boutique popular for its discount racks.

4.90 (218 reviews) (~90.88 km from centre)

Sunnyside Book and Media Swap, Public Library and Donation Center

Public library

👍👍 A concept difficult for some to understand: free books. This table is a labor of love. It’s a clean, friendly, well-lighted place, with books available for children as well as adults. It’s organized by a skeleton crew of volunteers, so the books are arranged mostly by size, but in general categories...

4.90 (45 reviews) (~84.44 km from centre)

Milton United Methodist Thrift Shop

Thrift store

👍👍 Wonderful place to donate clothes and help out. They are so appreciative for every single donation made. Everyone is friendly and beyond helpful. Just a great addition to our beautiful community!!! The people in this area are just alittle kinder, patient and family orientated. There's no other place...

4.90 (38 reviews) (~68.97 km from centre)

Barn Again Thrift Store

Thrift store

4.80 (48 reviews) (~25.22 km from centre)

Stray Vintage

Second hand store

Quirky selection of vintage jewelry, clothes & midcentury modern furniture, plus gifts & more.

4.80 (44 reviews) (~84.54 km from centre)

The Hunt

Second hand store

👍👍 What a great little store! The findings are amazing! A carefully picked mix of vintage and new. Everything so clean, organized and inviting. Customer service is the best. It just make you feel like you want to stay there for hours! It will not disappoint!

4.80 (39 reviews) (~50.5 km from centre)

Montclair Book Center

Book store

👍👍 Montclair is a very diverse and eccentric town. One of the places that adds to the charm is the Montclair Book Center. Since the new ownership took place (a little over a year ago), a majority of improvements have been made to enhance the bookreader and customer experience. The MBC transcends...

4.70 (469 reviews) (~78.6 km from centre)

That Nothing Be Lost Thrift

Thrift store

👍👍 The cleanest thrift store I’ve ever been too, and I’ve probably been to hundreds at this point . The home now turned thrift is very well organized, there isn’t just stuff everywhere. 3 floors plus the basement . Highly recommended!

4.70 (61 reviews) (~18.86 km from centre)

Wow! That's Unusual!

Thrift store

4.70 (54 reviews) (~44.68 km from centre)

Thrift Mart of New Milford Inc

Thrift store

👍👍 Love this place. Went for the first time today. Excellent prices on great items & wonderful staff. So glad my friend recommended it & we will definitely be back.

4.70 (31 reviews) (~49.59 km from centre)

thriftnicks

Thrift store

👍👍 Can’t think of a nicer guy in a business like this. The owner Nick helped me out tremendously for a bunch of things I needed and kept recommending more to really complete my trip. Prices are incredibly fair and if you talk to Nick you’ll get a couple cool stories from him as well. I’ve already recom...

4.60 (93 reviews) (~74.84 km from centre)

Red Owl Collective

Antique store

4.60 (61 reviews) (~47.48 km from centre)

Trinity Thrift Shop

Thrift store

4.60 (55 reviews) (~99.56 km from centre)

Affordable Finds Family Consignment

Consignment shop

4.60 (47 reviews) (~26.88 km from centre)

Tag Sale Warehouse

Thrift store

😐 A decent amount of items, but in general the prices are on the high side - many things still in original packaging (despite appearing to be 20+ years old), and is priced almost as if you’re buying it new in a traditional store. That said, decent prices on clothing, and AMAZING prices on physical me...

4.60 (38 reviews) (~65.45 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Thrift stores in Newburgh, United States