1
Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Dined in tonight with my husband and loved everything! From the moment you walk in you are welcomed with attentive and friendly staff. The appetizers were great, the Margerita and Bianca e Verde pizzas were *chef’s kiss* and dessert is a must! They have great offerings I have not seen in any other p...
4.90 (186 reviews)
2
Queen Margherita Trattoria
Italian restaurant
Quaint & cozy BYOB eatery dishing up traditional red-sauce Italian meals in a relaxed atmosphere.
$$ $$
4.60 (857 reviews)
3
Luna Wood Fire Tavern
Restaurant
Buzzy, family-owned bar/eatery with Italian & American dishes, plus gourmet pizza & outdoor seating.
$$ $$
4.50 (557 reviews)
4
Ralph's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Longtime dining room dishing out traditional Italian dishes & pizzas in a comfortable BYOB setting.
$$ $$
4.40 (1.3K reviews)
5
Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Great local spot - I’ve been on a pizza kick recently and decided to try give this place a try, using the grandma slice as my measure. I also ordered a slice of the Roma, which had chicken, broccoli, and mozzarella.
The grandma slice was excellent, great sauce to cheese to crust ratio. The Roma was...
$$ $$
4.40 (393 reviews)
6
Bell Paese Deli Pizzeria and Trattoria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Outstanding Italian pizzeria and the best Italian cuisine in Nutley by far.The owners create an authentic, welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel like family. The pasta is divine—cooked to perfection, and the subs are savory from the high-quality ingredients they use. As for the pizza, it's unpara...
$$ $$
4.40 (245 reviews)
7
Nonno’s Pizzeria Deli & Catering
Pizza restaurant
😠 Worked and lived near Cuginnis for a very long time and have been a continuous customer the whole time. Nothing but great things to say about the former owners. Great quality sandwiches that were awesome portions everytime. Cuginis was the go to spot for lunch. Sadly they have sold the place to the...
$ $$$
4.30 (234 reviews)
8
Rocky's. Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 I really enjoyed this pizza. The service was really good and they served me at a seat and I didn’t even ask. As well as them having good service they also have good pizza that was a pleasure to eat. It was really thin with a great flavor. I truly recommend for kids and adults. Oh and did I mention a...
$ $$$
4.30 (182 reviews)
9
NickyBoy’s Pizza Joint
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The ambiance, checkered tablecloths, frank sinatra playing. The service and the food were outstanding. I would definitely go back for dinner.
$$ $$
4.30 (50 reviews)
10
Cucina 355
Italian restaurant
👍👍 If you want, homemade Italian food with the grandma like feel, I highly recommend try this place out in the heart of nutley!
They are known for their arincini balls in vodka sauce, so I had to try them, and they were super delicious! I also tried their homemade meatballs with a side of ricotta and...
$$ $$
4.20 (621 reviews)
11
Loue's Place Pizza & Pasta
Pizza restaurant
😠 Don't order the Baked Ziti with meatballs. Even though it clearly says, "with meatballs," it won't come with meatballs. And if you call and ask about the meatballs, they will tell you over and over that it doesn't come with meatballs, even though the menu says it does. Quite confusing, and I guess...
$ $$$
4.10 (151 reviews)
12
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.
$ $$$
3.90 (220 reviews)
13
AMORE PIZZA by jack calandra
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The Giuseppe pizza is absolutely amazing, I've never tasted anythiing like it.
The variety of the pizzas, location, and parking are plusses.
$$ $$
3.90 (106 reviews)