Top rated Apartment rental agencies in West Islip

Experience the best that West Islip has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 35 places from Apartment rental agency category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Avalon Huntington Station image
1
Avalon Huntington Station
Apartment rental agency
😠 Don’t move here unless you want the following points… After living for one year in the Avalon I might be qualified to give a bigger feedback. The first impression of the Avalon is nice but that’s it. All in all I am more than disappointed by the Avalon in Huntington. These are the reasons why 1....
4.80 (243 reviews) (~18.3 km from centre)
Heritage Oyster Bay (formerly Norwich Gate Luxury Rentals) image
2
Heritage Oyster Bay (formerly Norwich Gate Luxury Rentals)
Apartment rental agency
👍👍 David is fantastic. He is super friendly, detailed, and answered all of my questions. 10/10 - thank you, David! 😊 Update as of 7/19 - David came back for another service request and he was able to quickly and efficiently fix my issue. He is such a pleasure to work with. Thank s again!
4.80 (144 reviews) (~25.6 km from centre)
Finest Realty Rental Specialist image
3
Finest Realty Rental Specialist
Real estate rental agency
👍👍 Good Afternoon, I would like to say thank you for the wonderful experience I had with Finest Realty. During the Pandemic my old Landlord sold his house. I was having such a difficult time in finding another rental. I came across Finest Realty Rental. I received a call from Doug. He immediatel...
4.80 (35 reviews) (~17.42 km from centre)
Avalon Commons image
4
Avalon Commons
Apartment rental agency
👍 New maintenance order on our blocked sink in bathroom is placed on the app. But the maintenance request is closed and no one came. This time I am mad for real. I have received so many emails from Avalon to place all maintenance requests through app. But when you actually place one, it stops working....
4.70 (317 reviews) (~19.94 km from centre)
New Village at Patchogue image
5
New Village at Patchogue
Apartment rental agency
👍👍 I lived in my own home for 50 years. My wife and I experienced circumstances requiring us to move. While considering apartments, we were disappointed in reviews for other rental properties. I remembered seeing New Village at Patchogue being built a few years ago and checked out the reviews from resi...
4.70 (161 reviews) (~25.44 km from centre)
Renaissance Bay Apartments image
6
Renaissance Bay Apartments
Apartment complex
😠 If you've read through other reviews you see they are mostly about maintenence which I agree do a fantastic job. With that being said why are these newly renovated units needing so much attention from maintenence is the question that arises. I've been here 3 weeks now and my overall experience is le...
4.60 (526 reviews) (~29.32 km from centre)
Colony Park Luxury Apartments image
7
Colony Park Luxury Apartments
Apartment building
😠 I’m living in this community from past 5 months. Heard good reviews about this place & we moved here. On Monday they turned off the water supply to my building without notifying anything, after calling to maintenance department got to know that due to emergency repairs they did so & then got a mail....
4.60 (517 reviews) (~17.78 km from centre)
Avalon Westbury image
8
Avalon Westbury
Apartment rental agency
😠 ABSOLUTE NIGHTMARE!!!...i am highly disappointed in the customer service at the front office, the maintenance workers are very rude and not compliant at all, especially when you're nice (i like to keep my carpets clean). After i requested help about a sweating ac unit i specifically asked to either...
4.60 (311 reviews) (~24.19 km from centre)
Avalon Rockville Centre image
9
Avalon Rockville Centre
Apartment rental agency
😠 I'm just here because as I was reading ALL the reviews and seeing the pictures and videos. Even though there was alot of positive feedback, avalon I have a question. Will you consider getting 24 hour surveillance so that peoples packages wont get taken? And how about the garbage pick up? Why was...
4.60 (274 reviews) (~29.35 km from centre)
Heatherwood Hillcrest Village Luxury Apartments image
10
Heatherwood Hillcrest Village Luxury Apartments
Apartment complex
4.60 (218 reviews) (~22.07 km from centre)
Heatherwood House at Oakdale image
11
Heatherwood House at Oakdale
Apartment complex
👍👍 I have been living here for a few years and I must say the maintenance team is always on top of everything! Whenever I’m in need they respond so quick. I adore the leasing team and community manager they are always so helpful and will do anything to help. I definitely recommend Heatherwood I love ca...
4.60 (69 reviews) (~16.41 km from centre)
Bunt Commons II image
12
Bunt Commons II
Apartment complex
😠 It is very rare that I give a bad review but I found Kate rude and unaccommodating. The type of person who always acts likes it is an inconvenience when you ask for something or even a question. Just a general nasty, bad attitude. She literally came out of the office screaming like a maniac once...
4.60 (36 reviews) (~7.52 km from centre)
Avalon Melville image
13
Avalon Melville
Apartment rental agency
4.50 (248 reviews) (~10.9 km from centre)
Heatherwood House at Patchogue image
14
Heatherwood House at Patchogue
Apartment rental agency
👍👍 Giving 5 star review TO MAINTENENCE ONLY. Corporate doesn't help in the slightest. Can't get calls back or emails responded to. Corporate also doesn't do any favors for their awesome maintenance guys here. Constant issues with the closet doors and they just keep having to come back and fix them. Jus...
4.50 (223 reviews) (~24.85 km from centre)
Mid Island Apartments image
15
Mid Island Apartments
Apartment complex
👍👍 Recently moved in with Mid-Island apartments and so far the leasing team and the Maintenance team have been great. The head of Maintenance, Rob, is very polite and quick in helping the tenants. Truly a nice guy who puts a lot of hard work into his job.
4.50 (170 reviews) (~6.38 km from centre)
Spruce Pond Luxury Apartments image
16
Spruce Pond Luxury Apartments
Apartment building
👍👍 Tom and Melinda are amazing and can’t thank them enough for making Heatherwood such a great place to live. They set up activities for the kids on memorial day which my kids loved! Any problem or situation someone may have, they are attentive, understanding and will do whatever they can to come to a...
4.40 (164 reviews) (~23.55 km from centre)
Avalon Garden City image
17
Avalon Garden City
Apartment rental agency
😠 Don't live here I'm 7 months pregnant with twins and moved to Avalon Garden City with my husband to settle down and get prepared for our growing family. Since living here, it has been the complete opposite! We have had: -water leaking from the roof directly into our bedroom that resulted in us not...
4.40 (154 reviews) (~24.37 km from centre)
Heatherwood House at Lake Ronkonkoma image
18
Heatherwood House at Lake Ronkonkoma
Apartment building
👍👍 So I as a realtor had to show a property to my client. I went to the leasing office and we were greater by Susan. She was more than helpful with my clients. In my opinion she went over and beyond to help. Thanks to her, my client is applying for the apartment. She helped thru the entire process. She...
4.40 (118 reviews) (~20.95 km from centre)
Alston image
19
Alston
Apartment rental agency
😠 Would give zero stars if I could. Parking is a NIGHTMARE. Everyone is parked illegally with no repercussions. I am often trapped in my parking spot most mornings and leaving for work turns into a major chore. People park on sidewalks and block the entry gates. What is management's solution? Valet pa...
4.40 (106 reviews) (~20.91 km from centre)
Birchwood Glen Co-Op image
20
Birchwood Glen Co-Op
Townhouse complex
👍👍 Went to show one of their units... beautiful, well kept and very spacious.
4.30 (39 reviews) (~24.66 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near West Islip

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )