Top rated Collectibles stores in West Islip

Experience the best that West Islip has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 22 places from Collectibles store category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


ACSB - American Coin, Stamp & Bullion Inc image
1
ACSB - American Coin, Stamp & Bullion Inc
Coin dealer
😠 Buyers beware. I purchased a coin here which I was told had a unique tint to it. I paid spot price for silver plus a decent premium. Long story short, I went to sell the coin I purchased from here probably a year ago. Turns out it was made of bronze. Zero silver content at all. This place will take...
5.00 (214 reviews) (~21.16 km from centre)
The Vintage Living image
2
The Vintage Living
Antique store
4.90 (76 reviews) (~28.92 km from centre)
Specialty Rarities image
3
Specialty Rarities
Coin dealer
👍👍 I went in there not knowing what to expect but to my surprise Jeff took the time to offer up an explanation for the various items that I brought in for evaluation and paid fair prices for the items. I will definitely be back and recommend this location. Thank you
4.90 (37 reviews) (~18.61 km from centre)
Grasshoppers Comics image
4
Grasshoppers Comics
Comic book store
Fixture with a wide selection of comics, trade paperbacks & graphic novels plus games & events.
4.80 (179 reviews) (~28.79 km from centre)
Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop image
5
Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop
Flea market
👍👍 Fabulous people, Jay and Pat are like meeting up with old friends. Shop is jam packed of great finds and you won't leave empty handed and you'll get a great deal, too. Highly recommend.
4.80 (69 reviews) (~21.46 km from centre)
Strange Love Parlor image
6
Strange Love Parlor
Collectibles store
4.80 (33 reviews) (~6.04 km from centre)
Time Warp Toys & Collectibles image
7
Time Warp Toys & Collectibles
Toy store
4.70 (214 reviews) (~23.6 km from centre)
Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center image
8
Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center
Antique store
👍👍 Huge amount of classic, vintage and antique items! If you can't find it here, I don't think exists! The diversity in items from booth to booth is amazing! Helpful, friendly staff helps to find just what they are looking for. Aniques, restored furniture, handmade items, Dixie Belle Chalk Paint, a...
4.60 (310 reviews) (~16.33 km from centre)
Brothers Grim Games and Collectibles image
9
Brothers Grim Games and Collectibles
Collectibles store
😐 Brothers Grimm is a really cool store in the sense of the items in stock and some of the Warhammer items they receive. I find some of the Pokemon and Video Games really cool. My boyfriend and I have been in there multiple times, and its cool to see some of the items in there. But it's difficult to g...
4.40 (462 reviews) (~27.35 km from centre)
GameStop image
10
GameStop
Video game store
Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.
$$ $$
4.40 (297 reviews) (~20.51 km from centre)
GameStop image
11
GameStop
Video game store
Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.
$$ $$
4.30 (133 reviews) (~3.4 km from centre)
GameStop image
12
GameStop
Video game store
Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.
$$ $$
4.30 (129 reviews) (~28.86 km from centre)
Eastern Numismatics Inc image
13
Eastern Numismatics Inc
Gold dealer
😠 This company appears to violate the national DO NOT CALL policy - enough said.
4.30 (94 reviews) (~27.57 km from centre)
GameStop image
14
GameStop
Video game store
Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.
$$ $$
4.20 (128 reviews) (~10.76 km from centre)
GameStop image
15
GameStop
Video game store
Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.
$$ $$
4.10 (188 reviews) (~29.34 km from centre)
Fantastic Toyage Inc image
16
Fantastic Toyage Inc
Toy store
4.10 (147 reviews) (~12.02 km from centre)
GameStop image
17
GameStop
Video game store
Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.
$$ $$
4.00 (221 reviews) (~3.68 km from centre)
GameStop image
18
GameStop
Video game store
Chain retailer offering new & used video games, plus consoles, controllers & related gear.
$$ $$
4.00 (92 reviews) (~25.68 km from centre)
Antique Market image
19
Antique Market
Antique store
3.80 (50 reviews) (~15.63 km from centre)
Land of Oohs & Oz image
20
Land of Oohs & Oz
Collectibles store
👍👍 Been here every so often since I was young and I Love this place. Owner usually appears very busy trying to keep this dying breed alive but is actually very knowledgeable and friendly. Do everyone a favor and leave your junk and hess trucks at home if you're looking to sell. I am always curious to...
3.80 (33 reviews) (~12.1 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near West Islip

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )