1
Smug's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The best pizza in the world. I mean it!
$ $$$
4.60 (102 reviews)
(~8.62 km from centre)
2
Dutchy's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😐 Meh. We got a large veggie pizza for $30 and we were told to pick it up in an hour. I've had way better pizza for $20 and faster. The best thing I got from there was the beer. The guy behind the counter seemed nice enough though and he was trying his best to keep up. He was courteous It did seem a...
$$ $$
4.50 (398 reviews)
(~8.39 km from centre)
3
Don's Donuts Pizza & Deli
Donut shop
😠 What happened to this place?! The last couple of times, spread over a 2 year window, that I have stopped in this place it is never open. Today they opened the door at 8:30 when the sign says 8. I used to stop on the way to school and get kids a donut but that is impossible now. It seems like the em...
$ $$$
4.40 (683 reviews)
(~8.66 km from centre)
4
Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata
Pizza restaurant
😐 Sometimes great, but inconsistent. Sometimes pizza comes out incredibly soggy, or you can taste that they havn't cleaned their ovens in a long time.
$$ $$
4.30 (648 reviews)
(~9.2 km from centre)
5
Smug's Pizza-McKinleyville
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 We just moved to this area from the east coast. Our family surprised us with dinner one night recently. They brought a a pie from Smug's for us. Originally being from the Philadelphia area I am a picky pizza person. This pie from Smug's hit it out of the ball park. The toppings are very generous, es...
$ $$$
4.30 (202 reviews)
(~0.94 km from centre)
6
Arcata Pizza & Deli
Pizza restaurant
Italian eatery offering specialty pies & a selection of hot & cold sandwiches, with veggie options.
$$ $$
4.20 (784 reviews)
(~8.56 km from centre)
7
Mazzotti's - Italian Restaurant
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Their doorway is where I slept my first night in Arcata. Can't say much about the food but it makes a great emergency shelter for the evening though it's a little close to the park which remains active throughout the night. It looks like they probably serve really good food. Definite five stars for...
$$ $$
4.20 (644 reviews)
(~8.79 km from centre)
8
Westside Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Branch of a regional chain known for its multiple sauce options & creative specialty pizzas.
$$ $$
4.20 (275 reviews)
(~9.03 km from centre)
10
Mountain Mike's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Just opened, great food! First order was inaccurate, giving a pass as they just opened and might still be figuring some stuff out. Will definitely come back. Hoping to have a winner in McKinleyville other than Starbucks!
EDIT: Updating to 5 stars. Last few orders have been accurate and food is deli...
4.10 (50 reviews)
(~1.48 km from centre)
12
Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Carry-out chain featuring chicken wings, signature breadsticks & pizza tossed from housemade dough.
$ $$$
3.90 (241 reviews)
(~0.56 km from centre)
13
Round Table Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Long-running chain serving pizzas with customizable toppings & sauces in a simple space.
$$ $$
3.90 (199 reviews)
(~0.45 km from centre)
14
Round Table Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Long-running chain serving pizzas with customizable toppings & sauces in a simple space.
$$ $$
3.70 (227 reviews)
(~5.12 km from centre)
15
Domino's Pizza
Pizza delivery
Delivery/carryout chain offering a wide range of pizzas & a variety of other dishes & sides.
$ $$$
3.30 (76 reviews)
(~8.02 km from centre)